A: There never was and never was. But it was because I contacted his Arabs several times, and then in the same month he left he said I would look for another apartment and leave, so he said, I'll look for another apartment and leave. I told him you need to bring another tenant in your place..."
- As Appendix A to Whitley's affidavit, text correspondence between him and Shiner was attached. Referring to the correspondence of March 2, 2022 (my emphases D.B.):
"Vitaly: Good evening Yoav, Starting tomorrow I will take and remove all my belongings from the apartment, tomorrow I will come to fix everything that is Such as: plaster, painting, etc... And immediately afterwards I can return the keys to you and at the same time take my security check... In addition, I will take pictures of the water and electricity clock and pay the bills.
Shiner: I do not approve and do not terminate the contract for you before its !! time
Vitaly: When does it say that the contract ends?
Shiner: In a few months, I think it's 9 months... I'm not playing with you I don't allow you to do whatever you want, I'll just file a lawsuit against you and the Arabs... And your bully is deposited in the bank tomorrow... Take care of the money please in the account
Vitaly: That the copy of the contract applies to me... Because I didn't sign, you just came and took more checks from me... Please... This month's check? March?
Shiner: I will submit it to the court... You can't leave in the middle of the year, you can't do whatever you want... You are violating an agreement and again I am not approving you!
Vitaly: A week ago, you called me and told me that there are people who want to move into the apartment this month, so I made sure to evict her... And now you're telling me there's a contract for almost another year?
...
And in addition, the rent is too expensive for me, I talked to you about it three months ago... I can't afford it