And later on -
I've done a lot of surgeries in my report, but the analyses in relation to air pollution levels are from Dr. Lebicki...... That's just one part of my review. I also look at data, health data that are related to Haifa and that are not dependent on the data of air monitoring, and I also talk about the reports of the plaintiffs' experts, and this too has nothing to do with Lebiki's opinion (page 2190).
- Livki was asked in this context: "...So I ask you again, assuming we don't have data, we take out her opinion, she doesn't exist, come and show me your opinion and that the things Rodriquez wrote stand on their own?", and she replied:
I want to make it clear that I stand behind what I answered. The data of air monitoring is very important and they show that the levels of pollutants are lower than levels that cause health risks. The only point I wanted to make is that in addition to this, in addition to this important analysis, there is more data, more analyses that support these opinions.
[....] The only point I wanted to make is that in addition to this, this analysis of the calculation regarding the air monitoring data also has other analyses that support the conclusions in the reports, and what is important is that they all show that the reports of the experts on behalf of the plaintiffs are invalid. During the break, I checked the three reports to see where the surgeries in them were based on the surgeries or Dr. Libicki's data, so here's my answer. In relation to the Dr. Rodriguez report from 2016, only section 3.4. In relation to the Rodriguez report from 2020, paragraphs 2.2 and 2.3, and in relation to my opinion, paragraphs 4.2 and 4.3, but in relation to section 4.3, I would like to say that there I also relied on data from the World Health Organization's air monitoring, and all this illustrates that although these analyses by Livki are very important, in general, very important for the purpose of my opinion, There are many other important analyses that are not dependent on this data (pages 2446-2447).