Investigators' arrival at the scene, the beginning of the investigation and findings at the scene
- The two paramedics who were called to the scene first arrived at the scene, namely, Tal Shachar and Muhammad Shibli. They both found the deceased facing the floor. Yes, the electric bike was between his legs. They noticed a head injury and noted that the deceased had not communicated with them (see exhibits P/193 and P/194 submitted with consent).
- As mentioned above, the incident was initially reported as a road accident. Yes, police officers Khalil Ali (who edited exhibit P/1, submitted with consent) and Ashmoz Rodin (who edited exhibit P/2, submitted with consent) arrived at the scene. As they both stated in their reports, when they arrived at the scene, they noticed an MDA patrol car, which was already at the scene and the injured man was inside the vehicle. The police wrote down the investigative actions they carried out at the time. They interrogated people who had gathered at the scene of the incident and scanned for security cameras in the area. Furthermore, as it appears that one of the civilians who goes by the name Israel Madar said that he had contacted his brother Yusef Madar and asked about the details of the incident, and the latter told him that boys had told him that someone had been attacked. The policeman added that apart from that, all those who were in the vicinity thought it was an incident that originated in a car accident.
- At a certain point, at 01:29, a report was received from Dr. Segal from the hospital in Afula (see P/6), from which it emerged that during the treatment of the injured man, it was clarified that this was a stabbing incident and not a road accident. As a result, the status of the investigation was changed, and investigators from the Northern District Attorney's Office arrived at the scene. (See P/34 by Superintendent Adv. Hodaya Zeno Amsalem, "An Addendum to the Circumstances of the Case").
- As stated above, upon learning of the nature of the incident, a number of investigators were called to the scene and began their work; Investigator Danny Bitan, Investigator David Huli, Meir Dahan, Hodaya Zeno Amsalem and Sheetrit Moshe. Yes, a mobile forensic laboratory arrived at the scene of the incident. It is clear that, when they arrived at the scene, the body of the deceased was no longer there. In this context, reference can be made to Exhibit A/7 prepared by Policeman Meir Dahan, from which it appears that when he arrived at the scene of the incident, he searched the scene and in the meantime the defendant's mother, who was in a panic, arrived, screaming and looking for her son. The policeman reassured her and then asked her about the presence of security cameras in her home.
- In the framework of P/50, the interrogator Huli documented, His work, After arriving at the scene of the incident on the night of the murder. As it turns out, he died./50 He noticed blood stains on the road, When the deceased was no longer at the scene. Together with Danny Bitan and others, he went to the home of the defendant's mother, From', and asked to receive the security camera footage. At the same time, it was clarified to them, Because the defendant was not at home. The defendant's mother said, Because her son was not at home at the time and she was even looking for him.
- From the exhibit Exhibit P/26 edited by researcher Danny Bitan, Rising, Because Bitan arrived at the scene on the day 21.1.16 Together with other investigators and officers. When he gets there, The body of the deceased was no longer at the scene. Dead/26 Rising, Because Bitan received information from Meir Dahan according to which, When the latter arrived at the family's home ***; The landlady came out to him and asked him shoutingly what happened to her son and also noted that she had security cameras. Accordingly, Contacted Danny Bitan together with the researcher Huli, Hodaya Amsalem Zeno and Shitrit Moshe to the scene, Talk to M' (The landlady, The Defendant's Mother) and asked to copy the security tape. At that point, Noted from' that her son, Ben 17 He was not at home and added in a statement, Because she doesn't know where he is..
At that point, the police asked the defendant's mother for the security cameras. It should be noted that at first she refused their request. However, after she made a phone call and sent a text message using her phone, she agreed to hand over the security cameras to the police (see Bitan's testimony before us, p. 72, lines 9-18).
- As part of the investigation process and tracing findings that will help investigators solve the murder, security cameras were seized. One of the security cameras was observed by the interrogator Huli (in this context, see - A/49, Duo"Viewing security cameras located in the home of the witness'). Note, Because these are two cameras, with the camera not' 3 Facing the street ***. While viewing the security cameras at the relevant times of the day 20.1.16 Between the hours 22:00 Up to 23:59, The cyclist was observed (At 1 o' 22:58:50) Passing from right to left. From then until the time 23:26:22 The cyclist was seen passing on the street several times (7 Times). Here is the place to note, Because , In accordance with T/49, The time that appears on the camera is three minutes ahead of the actual time (See, Name, A/49 pp' 1, Section 2).
More, See T/63 Concerned with two"Viewing the home cameras of the **** which was edited by researcher Gili Alon. Name, The deceased was seen riding a bicycle, Making his way down the street *** Towards the street *** and evacuate ***, And this is around an hour 22:54, And at the same time, Viewed Guy Dressed C'Jeans and a light coat as he runs towards the street *** And at the time 22:55 The same guy was seen walking back towards the street *** and continues towards the street ***. Ltd.' 5 Name, The researcher noted, Because the guy was seen reaching back towards the back pants pocket. More, Because he looks like he's stuffing something in his pocket, While walking down the street *** (1 hour 22:55). Ltd.' 6 Ledo"VIII, The researcher noted, Because while walking from a street corner *** (Towards the street ***), The guy was seen looking back a few times (22:56).