Caselaw

Labor Dispute (Haifa) 61090-02-25 The Israeli Center L.A. Reshet Ltd. – Guy Yanchik - part 3

November 5, 2026
Print

III.      The Tribunal's Decision in the Claim

  1. Introduction to the Tribunal's Decision - We will preface the beginning, and note that after hearing the testimonies of the witnesses who testified before us, we considered all the arguments of the parties and went over the court file as a whole. We have reached the conclusion that the law of the lawsuit To be rejected in its entirety, its length and breadth.  Below we will detail how we reached this conclusion.

III.1.  The first statistic that acts upon the obligation of the plaintiff's version and arguments is the delay in filing the claim

  1. We will first note the The Significant Delay in Filing the Claim, which was not explained at all by the plaintiff during the course of the proceeding. We emphasize that we are dealing with a dramatic claim of a dramatic nature, in which weighty and significant claims were made by the plaintiff against the defendant.  In this framework, the plaintiff claimed that on the 19.10.2021 The defendant copied her business information.  Despite this, The lawsuit was filed only on the day 24.2.2025 - About three and a half years after the alleged events occurred.  Notwithstanding the aforesaid, the plaintiff did not give any explanation in the statement of claim for her puzzling conduct.
  2. When the plaintiff's counsel was asked during the preliminary hearing regarding the issue of the delay, he noted that "If the court considers the timing of the filing of the claim to be a question that requires clarification, I promise that we will address this in the affidavits."[1]. However, no such reference was made in the plaintiff's affidavits.  When the owner Danielle was asked during her testimony about the issue of the date of filing the lawsuit, she claimed that she gave birth in the year 2021, and also dealt with other matters related to the business, as well as the handling of the defendant's claim against the plaintiff[2].  A similar answer was given by Director Tzachi, who also referred to the consequences of the coronavirus pandemic and the "Iron Sword" war[3].
  3. This is not a substantive response, since it was first brought in their testimonies. The Shoval couple did not explain when the owner Daniel returned from maternity leave.  They also did not detail how the business operated during and after her absence, including through her husband, who manages Tzachi.  In any event, a period of about3.5 years go on far beyond what they claim regarding maternity leave or the coronavirus pandemic.  All this, especially in light of the defendant's very serious actions, as claimed by the plaintiff.
  4. The plaintiff's delay raises another question, since not only are these very serious allegations, but we are also dealing with the considerable damage that was allegedly caused to the plaintiff, and the enormous amount of information taken from her by the defendant, who copied "... The defendant's business information (Must be a "plaintiff" - the court's note) which includes all information and/or documents and/or a list of customers and/or a list of suppliers and/or trade secrets and/or any data regarding the Company and/or hardware and/or software and/or financial data and/or computer files and/or computer material (hereinafter: "Business Information")"[4].
  5. It is very puzzling in our eyes how such a serious act, which allegedly caused the plaintiff such significant damage, did not cause any change in her business conduct. To be precise, this is not a mere legal claim, but also a significant question mark: how is it possible that the plaintiff functioned, if at all, for about a period of about3.5 years, when the defendant allegedly carried out a massive erasure action "...  Within the shared cloud storage used by the entire sales department"[5]?!
  6. Moreover, the plaintiff also claimed that "The damage caused to the company is real. The deletion of the databases directly harmed the ability to contact existing customers, to track leads, to continue the procedures of closing deals, and to maintain business continuity.  This is a significant business and economic damage that has damaged the core of the company's operations and its painstakingly built reputation"[6].  However, these claims were not substantiated in any way by the plaintiff, as we will see below.
  7. In her testimony, the owner Daniel claimed that "All The file", which was deleted by the defendant, and that "... The file was managed in Drive, Google Sheets, it had a name, phone, emails, contact details, their professional classification with CEOs, marketing managers, salespeople, what active websites they have...  Every interaction with a customer is there"[7].  When asked again"What was deleted? Everything was deleted? All professional material deleted? Everything?", she replied that "Yes"[8].  When she was asked again "...  Were you left without any business information at all of the sales department?", she replied "True"[9].
  8. This was also evident from the testimony of Director Tzachi, who similarly claimed that "He erased everything", and also that"There were contacts with phones, emails, their addresses, key people, their mobile phones, correspondence, what we did with them, agreements, there were also agreements we signed, I couldn't continue with people agreements because I didn't know what I signed with them, I had to ask them for the agreement to see what I signed, there was a lot of information, there were also a lot of photos that were deleted but it was in the shared drive"[10].
  9. Unlike them, the computer supervisor Shai claimed in his testimony that only "Some of the files" Deleted[11]. Another contradiction can be found in the testimony of manager Tzachi, who claimed that only a few employees in the plaintiff had access to the alleged folder ("And for those who have access to it, the shared drive is me, Daniel, Shai and the sales agents only, even the CEO doesn't have access to this folder"[12]); and the testimony of Shai, who argued differently from him, regarding the attitude of all of the plaintiff's employees ("Start counting? Like salespeople, I know they seemed to me 4 At that time, Guy, Tal, some other 2-3....  There were crew members, as if graphic artists, programmers, me and others 2 We were at the time"[13]).
  10. In any event, from the claims of the owner Daniel and the manager Tzachi, it also emerged that a database that is most relevant to the plaintiff's activity - and in fact, All Its Database - Deleted Fully In light of the defendant's actions: "... I say that we did everything we could to restore this system and unfortunately the backup did not work and did not work"[14] (CEO Daniel) and "...  It deleted all data..." (Principal Tzachi).  Despite this, they did not explain how the plaintiff may have continued to conduct business in a business manner, and how it could be explained that the business survived, and was not closed immediately.  Moreover, it is not at all clear how a veteran and well-established business company like the plaintiff manages without backing up the alleged files.
  11. It should also be emphasized that it was also not claimed that any restoration operation was carried out by any of the plaintiff's parties regarding the files that were allegedly deleted by the defendant. Indeed, the owner Daniel claimed in her testimony that the plaintiff contacted Google to perform a restoration, but the attempt failed[15].  However, these claims were raised for the first time in her testimony, and here too - without any reference or objective evidence.  In contrast, Shai, the computer supervisor, claimed that he did not know whether it was possible at that time to recover the files that were allegedly deleted: "I don't know if it was at the time, I didn't find it"[16].  Again, therefore, it can be seen that the plaintiff's witnesses contradicted each other.
  12. On the other hand, The defendant's argument that the filing of the claim in this proceeding, at the end of the month, was not contradicted 2/2025 and shortly before the evidence hearing held in the month 3/2025 In the parallel proceeding, in a lawsuit that he himself filed against the plaintiff, suspecting her of having sought to deter him from exercising his rights. Let us clarify that This statement is not intended at all, and on the merits of the matter regarding the parallel proceeding, which is not in our care.  In any event, that proceeding has not yet been decided, and it is certainly possible that the claim there, and as it was filed by the defendant against the plaintiff, will be dismissed in its entirety.  All we note is the date of filing the claim in this proceeding, in close proximity to the time that was not explained in any way by the plaintiff, to the parallel proceeding.
  13. It was also proven by the defendant that the same procedural conduct was carried out by the plaintiff towards the employee Tal, But in the end, she gave up her lawsuit against him altogether.. See the affidavit of the employee Tal, who stated that he filed a claim in 2010 2022 against the plaintiff, following various remedies in labor law (labor dispute (Haifa) 2305-05-22 [Nevo]), and that on the day when the evidentiary hearing in this proceeding was supposed to be held, he was given a copy of the letter of claim filed by the plaintiff against him, in the sum of 350,000 ILS (the same amount that the defendant was required to pay in this proceeding), which was identical in his claims to those claimed against the defendant.
  14. The employee Tal went on to describe that he was very stressed, and his attorney on behalf of the Legal Aid Bureau even advised him to compromise with the plaintiff. In light of this, he agreed to a settlement for a lower sum than he thought he was entitled to.  In return, the plaintiff agreed to delete the lawsuit she filed against him, and the parties agreed that she would not be able to resubmit[17].
  15. When the owner Daniel was asked in her testimony why and why the plaintiff acted as described above, she did not provide a real answer, and claimed that it was agreed between the plaintiff and the employee Tal that this was a "secret" compromise[18]: "To the best of my recollection there is an appendix of secrecy". Beyond the fact that this claim was (also) first made in her testimony, it was also not proven.  In fact, the opposite is true: it is a false claim.  See the transcript of the hearing from 4.9.2024 In a labor dispute 2305-05-22 [Nevo], which was heard before the Honorable Judge Shai: "The claim filed by the defendant 1 per day 3.9.24 against the defendants Tal Shlomo Cohen and Eti Gadilov, will be rejected or deleted, without the possibility of resubmitting it"[19].  In other words, there is no "secrecy" here.
  16. Therefore, a real question remains - why and why did the plaintiff completely waive the same serious allegations that she had raised in the past against the employee Tal, and as they were raised in this proceeding against the defendant? It can therefore be concluded that the plaintiff waived all of her serious allegations against the employee Tal, after she had taken an improper procedural course of action against him and by abusing the court proceedings.

III.2.  A second statistic that serves the plaintiff's version and claims - the failure to prove the existence of a database in the plaintiff

  1. At the beginning of the decision on the merits of the matter, it should be noted that The plaintiff did not prove that she had any database at the time of the incident attributed to the defendant, and in particular a database containing trade secrets. The plaintiff made many arguments regarding "high-quality databases" that include "layers of business information, " including "a broad collection of data accumulated over the years." However, Not the slightest objective evidence of this has been brought, and the plaintiff's affidavits were accompanied by completely irrelevant information, such as photos of real estate conferences in which the plaintiff participated[20], or invoices for these conferences[21].
  2. See, for example, the affidavit of the owner, Daniel.[22]:

"It is important to clarify that the information accessible from the computer that was made available to Guy was not simple technical information or random files, but rather part of what we in the company call business information layers.  This is a vast collection of data accumulated over the years, which includes records of customer inquiries, lead classifications, documentation of professional interactions, private mobile phones of project managers, internal work documents, and unique work templates built from the accumulated experience of all teams.  This information constitutes the infrastructure on which the sales department operates, and it allows a salesperson to understand who the impairment is, what his contact history is, what are the correct entry points for the conversation, and what is required to promote the disability in the process.  Access to this information gives a clear advantage to salespeople, as it contains information that allows you to instantly contact and talk to the right person in order to offer him the service he needs, but he has not yet worked to achieve."

  1. See also the affidavit of the person in charge of computing Shai[23]:

"The company's databases, and especially the databases of leads and customers, are the business heart of the activity.  This is the main asset on which the salespeople, headed by Guy during his tenure, generated revenue.  The database is not a "phone list" that can be obtained from an Internet search.  It is the result of years of hard work, both physical and digital, during which the company collected, filtered and processed data from real estate projects, contractors, business entities, conferences, exhibitions and business meetings.

Previous part123
4...18Next part
Skip to content