Do you know that feeling when you have been working in an organization for years, investing your soul, and when an internal tender is published for a management position you have been waiting for - you feel that the result has been marked in advance? Or maybe you are an external supplier who is most suitable for the tender, but it seems that one of the committee members has accumulated anger towards you in the past or a senior manager threw a critical remark at you years ago. Imagine walking into the meeting room, your heart pounding, and frustration leading you to accuse the committee of discrimination, declare the tender invalid, get up and storm out of the room. This is a human and understandable reaction out of a storm of emotions - but will this dramatic step protect you in court or actually cause you to fail in the tender?
Israeli Courts impose a strict duty on a tender committee to act fairly, equally and with an open mind. However, committee members do not operate in a vacuum - prior acquaintance with the bidder in the tender is completely natural and therefore the case law distinguishes between "prior opinion" and "prejudice". Prior opinion is a reasonable initial impression, while prejudice is a "locked" position that cannot be changed, and only it disqualifies the committee member.
As a general rule, a bidder participating in a tender despite knowing about a flaw may be considered as someone who agreed to the "rules of the game" and will be precluded from raising his claims later, to the extent that he does not win the tender. Thus, for example, in a case discussed in the Supreme Court in December, 2023, it was a lawyer who competed in a tender of the Ministry of Finance. The lawyer claimed that there were material flaws in the tender, but after his claims were rejected by the tender committee, he submitted his proposal and only after submitting it, petitioned to cancel the tender. The Supreme Court ruled that the general rule precluding recourse to the courts after submitting a proposal for a tender has exceptions and in any case the court has discretion to allow a petition, including in the case of claims of severe illegality or harm to the rule of law or when objections were submitted to the tender committee and it rejected them at the last moment and a proposal was submitted "under protest". In contrast, in a case discussed in the National Labor Court, in March, 2026, a veteran lifeguard in the Tel Aviv Municipality competed for the position of station manager, claimed that the tender was 'invalid' due to an old statement by the municipality's CEO 9 years earlier which he claimed created prejudice against him, and in a storm of emotions abandoned the room and refused to continue the tender process. The National Labor Court rejected his request to freeze the tender and determined that he did not give the committee a chance to examine his candidacy at all by leaving the room.
Therefore, if you have encountered a flaw or a fear of conflict of interest, in certain cases it is better to continue participating in the tender process "under protest" provided that the concrete flaw is explicitly defined (for example, conflict of interest or prejudice of a certain committee member), and it is desirable to direct the protest to the authorized body in writing before the decision is made, demand a record in the protocol or a correction of the procedure (such as replacing a committee member) and continue to compete so as not to harm your chances. Equally important is to be accompanied by a lawyer with experience in the field, since professional legal management in real time will ensure the drafting of the correct protest, proper documentation of the flaws and protection of your rights without falling into expensive procedural traps. A gut reaction, demonstrative abandonment or silence until the results are published may irreversibly thwart your legal rights.

