| In the Supreme Court sitting as a Court of Appeals for Administrative Matters |
| Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 |
| 30פני: | The Honorable Judge D. Barak-Erez |
| The Honorable Judge G. Kanfi-Steinitz | |
| The Honorable Judge Y. Kasher |
| The Appellant: | Zvi Ben-Eliezer |
| Against |
| Respondent: | State of Israel – Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense |
| Applicant to join as an “amicus curiae”: |
Israel Bar Association |
| Appeal against the judgment of the Jerusalem District Court (Judge A. Avman-Müller), dated January 16,2023, in AP 58562-05-22 [Published in Nevo] |
| Date of Meeting: | 26 Iyar 5783 | (17.5.2023) |
| On behalf of the appellant: | Adv. Pini Gilad | |||
| On behalf of RespondentE: | Adv. Avi Twig | |||
| On behalf of the Applicant to join as an “amicus curiae”: |
Adv. Eran Zohar |
|||
Judgment
Judge Y. Kasher:
- Appeal against the judgment of the Jerusalem District Court (the Honorable Judge Avman-Muller), dated January 16,2023, in AP 58562-05-22 [published in Nevo].
- The appeal concerns tender No. 1001/2022, which was published on February 17,2022, by the State of Israel - the Ministry of Finance (hereinafter: the Respondent), for the selection of suppliers for the provision of professional examination services of municipal taxation imposed on government ministries and handling their reduction (the title of the tender: "Examination of municipal taxation charges of government ministries (including the Ministry of Defense) and treatment for their reduction by law firms"; hereinafter: the tender). The tender was referred to law firms that meet the professional threshold conditions defined therein.
- The appellant is the owner of a law firm that deals with the field of municipal taxation, and he is one of the bidders in the tender that is the subject of the appeal. It should be noted that by virtue of past tenders held by the respondent in the field, the appellant's office provides the respondent, moving to the tender in question, with legal services in the field of the subject of the tender.
Background and the proceedings in the District Court
- The first tender in connection with the services that are the subject of the petition was published in 2010, and its number is 16/2010 (hereinafter: the 2010 tender). Within the framework of this tender, the bidders were required to submit proposals according to one of two alternatives: first, a joint proposal submitted by a professional company that deals with the examination of municipal taxation charges together with a law firm specializing in the field; the second, the submission of a proposal by a law firm specializing in the field, which will employ professionals in the required fields on its behalf. Two petitions were filed against the tender to the Jerusalem District Court (AP 57884-03-11 and AP 11579-04-11) [published in Nevo]; which were rejected in a judgment of October 23,2011 (Judge Ben Or).
This Court, in the framework of the appeal filed against the judgment in the following petitions"L, determined that the first alternative to entering into a tender violates the Article 58 Law Israel Bar Association, התשכ"A-1961 (hereinafter: The Bar Association Law or The Law), which prohibits a lawyer from engaging in a partnership with someone who is not a lawyer, or sharing his income. This is because in the absence of a separation between the payment to the law firm and the salary of the management company (who submitted a joint proposal), there is in fact a sharing of revenues between the two entities. In accordance with this determination, the court ordered the cancellation of the 2010 tender (77"m 8539/11 Malka Engelsman & Co. - Law Firm v. Ministry of Finance [Posted inNevo] (July 5,2012) (hereinafter: The Engelsman Matter)).
- Following the judgment in the Engelsman case, in 2012, the Respondent published a new tender No. 15/2012 (hereinafter: the Suppliers' Tender). The bidding mechanism set out in the suppliers' tender is one of cooperation between a law firm and a professional company, which will operate as "supplier pairs", but will submit separate bids (specifying the other bidder with whom the cooperation will be), in order to avoid revenue sharing between the entities.
In the 2012 tender, three won "Couples Offer", including the proposal of the appellant's office and the management company "Urban". By virtue of this winning of the suppliers' tender from 2012, the appellant provides services to the respondent in the field of the subject matter of the tender.
- As a supplementary tender to the suppliers' tender, the Respondent held, in 2016, a tender intended to select a body to manage the handling of municipal tax charges of government ministries: Tender Hat/M-1 "for the selection of service providers for government ministries on the subject of managing the handling of municipal tax charges, fees and levies, including water and sewage" (hereinafter: the management tender). This tender was won by a management company (Ida Management and Economic Consulting Ltd.); hereinafter: the management company), and an external law firm (Moskowitz, Azruel - Law Office; hereinafter: the accompanying firm).
In clause 6.5 of the management tender, it was noted that, alongside the individual handling of the municipal taxation charges that will be carried out by the winners of the suppliers' tender, and in circumstances justifying this, "Individual charges will be handled by the management company and the law firm that won this tender".
- On February 17,2022, the tender that is the subject of the appeal was published, which was intended to replace the 2012 suppliers' tender (the "tender" as defined at the beginning of this judgment). In the tender, the form of engagement with the winning suppliers was changed: the "supplier pairs" mechanism (cooperation between law firms and professional firms) was canceled; so that only law firms are permitted to submit bids within the framework of the tender. At the same time, it was determined in the tender that for the purpose of providing professional services accompanying the legal services that the winners would provide to the Respondent, the winners would be entitled to engage with professional companies if necessary.
In addition, within the framework of the tender, positions were assigned to a management company and the accompanying firm (which, as stated, won the management tender from 2016): "Each supplier will be required to cooperate and comply with the instructions of the management company and the law firm"d. The accompanying [...] including the possibility of transferring the handling and/or representation to the management company and the law firm"d. The lender, according to the Director-General's decision" (Clause 9 of the tender). In addition, a provision was included in the tender granting the respondent discretion to transfer files to the handling of the lending firm or the management company, instead of the suppliers winning the tender (sections 104-105). These provisions complement clause 6.5 of the management tender, which was cited above.
- From the date of publication of the tender for the first time, in February 2022, until the deadline for submitting bids (on May 22,2022), the appellant contacted the respondent several times in connection with the tender, as follows:
On March 6,2022, the appellant sent a number of clarification questions in relation to the tender and its terms. Following the clarification questions addressed to the tenders committee, including the appellant's questions, it was decided to change the prerequisites and quality requirements in the tender, a change that required its re-publication (the amended tender was published on April 13,2022). The day before the publication of the amended tender, on April 12,2022, the appellant asked additional clarification questions. With the publication of the amended tender, on April 13,2022, a response was provided to the clarification questions that were sent, including the appellant's questions from April 12,2022 (hereinafter: Answering the clarification questions). On May 1,2022, about two weeks before the deadline for submitting proposals, the appellant wrote to the tenders committee, and in this framework he laid out his arguments for material defects that fell in his view in the tender. On May 11,2022, the tenders committee convened to discuss the appellant's claims, and decided that there was no reason to accept the arguments, both because of the stage at which they were made (after the deadline for sending clarification questions), and because they were provided with a substantive response in response to the clarification questions. On May 17,2022, the Legal Bureau of the Ministry of Finance replied to the appellant that his arguments in his letter of May 1,2022 were rejected.