Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 2

December 10, 2023
Print

The deadline for submitting bids for the tender was May 22,2022.  The next day, the bidding box for the tender was opened, which also included the appellant's proposal.

  1. It should already be noted that in the framework of submitting his bid for the tender, the appellant signed Appendix B to the tender ("Law Firm Bid Form"), in which the following declaration was included, in clause 11: "I have carefully read all the details of this tender and all its appendices, I hereby declare that I have understood the requirements, that I meet the requirements and that I agree to the terms of the engagement and the attached contract that constitute an integral part of your order, and accordingly I prepared this proposal" (emphasis added - Y. 20).
  2. Three days after the opening of the bid box, on May 26,2022, the appellant submitted to the Jerusalem Court for Administrative Affairs the administrative petition that is the subject of the appeal in question (AP 58562-05-22) [published in Nevo]. Within the framework of the petition, the relief was requested: "to order the cancellation of the tender and the holding of a new tender, without the involvement of the management company and the accompanying law firm, in which all the material defects in the tender will be"
  3. Even before the appellant's petition (and before the deadline for submitting proposals), another administrative petition was filed against the tender, on April 25,2022, by a professional company that won the 2012 suppliers' tender (in a joint bid with a law firm), which attacked the engagement mechanism in the tender in question. This petition was rejected in the judgment of the Jerusalem Court for Administrative Affairs (Judge   Avman-Muller), dated January 16,2023 (AP 44075-04-22 Ofir Rifand Ltd.  v.  State of Israel [published in Nevo] (January 16,2023) (hereinafter: the Rifand case)).
  4. The appellant's arguments in the petition were divided into three main arguments:

           First, The appellant claimed that there was a conflict of interest Built-in in a tender, because its provisions make the management company and the accompanying office in practice service providers according to the tender (by virtue of the provisions that allow the transfer of files for their handling), alongside the management services they provide by virtue of the management tender.  It was argued that at the same time, there is a concern of a conflict of interest on the part of the lending firm and the management company, both in their involvement in the design of the tender terms and in their involvement in the stage of examining the bids and selecting the winners.  On this level, the appellant claimed that the lending firm and the management company maintain professional and business relations with some of the bidders in the tender.

Previous part12
3...32Next part
Skip to content