Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 3

December 10, 2023
Print

The appellant's position in the petition was that it should be included in the tender Prerequisites (as opposed to the conflict of interest provision included in the body of the tender, in sections 98-101), which prohibits a person who maintains a business or professional relationship with the management company or with the accompanying firm from submitting a bid for a tender, or alternatively that the engagement with such a bidder will be subject to an individual conflict of interest arrangement.

 

Second, the appellant argued that the provisions of the tender violate a number of clauses inThe Bar Association Law andRules of the Israel Bar Association (Professional Ethics), 5746-1986 (Hereinafter: Rules of Ethics; The Law and the Rules of Ethics will be referred to as follows: Ethics Law).  In essence, the appellant argued that the possibility of transferring files to the management company, which is not a law firm, violates the Article 20 to the Law Regarding the Uniqueness of the Profession; and that the lack of distinction in the tender between fees and reimbursement of expenses is contrary Section 85 Law and section 44 To the rules of ethics.

Third, the appellant claimed that there was a material flaw in the tender in the method of scoring the quality of the proposals, in thatUnreasonable weight is given to the size of the bidder (the number of lawyers per bidder), and the number of cases and proceedings handled by the bidder in the years 2020-2021.  The appellant argued that the high weight given to the said indices was intended to "tailor the tender to the size of two specific law firms".

  1. Simultaneously with the filing of the petition, the appellant filed an application for an interim order. On June 24,2022, the respondent filed a response to this request.  Two days later, and in accordance with the court's decision, the respondent announced on June 26,2022 that it wished to view its response to the request for an interim order as a preliminary response to the petition as well.

In accordance with the notice on behalf of the Respondent, the petition was set for hearing on June 30,2022.  At the beginning of the hearing, he asked"The appellant said that the hearing would focus on the request for an interim injunction, and that the hearing of the petition on its merits would be postponed to another date.  The court ordered that the hearing be held on the merits of the petition.  At the end of the hearing, he noted"The appellant argues that according to his position, his procedural rights were violated by holding the hearing of the petition at such a time close to the date of filing the reply.

Previous part123
4...32Next part
Skip to content