Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 4

December 10, 2023
Print

Shortly after the hearing, the appellant filed a motion to amend the minutes of the hearing, to which the respondent agreed (with the exception of one reservation).  The court accepted the request in part in its decision of August 19,2022 (the judge A.  Avman-Müller); while with regard to a small part of the requested amendments, including agreed amendments, the request was denied.  These amendments included, inter alia, matters in the order in which the defendant said the"20 Parties and comments made by the court itself during the hearing.

  1. On July 3,2022, the Trial Court (Judge Avman-Muller) decided to apply and expand an interim order given in the Rifand case (decision of May 4,2022), to the petition that is the subject of the appeal in this case.  Accordingly, the publication of the winners of the tender was prohibited; and the court ordered that "proposals shall not be forwarded for the handling and review of the accompanying law firm."
  2. On October 6,2022, the appellant filed a motion to add the other bidders in the tender as respondents to the petition, after he learned that the respondent had informed the bidders regarding the filing of the petition. The respondent objected to this request.  It should be noted that the District Court did not render its decision on this application before the main judgment in the proceeding was rendered.
  3. On January 1,2023, a hearing was held before the trial court on the appellant's request to provide additional details. The request was rejected at the end of the hearing (Judge   Avman-Muller).
  4. On January 16,2023, the Trial Court (Judge Avman-Muller) issued a judgment that rejected the petition.

The Trial Court's Judgment

  1. The trial court, in its ruling, rejected the petition, except with regard to the involvement of the accompanying firm in examining the bidders' proposals, for the reasons that will be detailed below.
  2. Delay - The District Court insisted that although the appellant's objections were rejected, he chose to submit his bid for the tender, and thus expressed agreement to its terms. The administrative petition was filed on May 26,2022, four days after the bid box was closed, more than three months after the tender was first published and more than a month after the publication of the amended tender.  This, it was held, is contrary to the precedent according to which claims of defects in the tender should be raised as soon as possible, and without the appellant providing a satisfactory explanation of the timing of the submission.  Therefore, the trial court ruled that the petition suffers from subjective delay.

On the plain The objective delay, the trial court noted that in the time that elapsed from the publication of the tender until the filing of the petition, resources were invested on the part of the respondent and on the part of the tender participants.  In addition, it was determined that the delay in filing the petition causes damage to the public interest in preventing the holding of the tender on the date set by the respondent; In this regard, the court added that: "All this time [In which the tender is delayed - 10:20] Continuation of the winners of the previous tender [Suppliers' Tender - 10:20], including the Petitioner, to provide services to the Respondent".

Previous part1234
5...32Next part
Skip to content