Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 5

December 10, 2023
Print

Therefore, the court ruled that the petition should be dismissed out of hand.  More than necessary, the court also discussed the appellant's arguments on their merits.

  1. Conflict of interest - the trial court rejected the appellant's entire argument in relation to an "inherent conflict of interest" in the terms of the tender. In this regard, it was held that the appellant's arguments constitute in fact an indirect attack on the management tender from 2016, where the functions of the lending firm and the management company were defined, including the possibility that files will be transferred to them; where the provisions of the tender that the appellant attacks in his petition were determined in accordance with the provisions of the management tender.  Therefore, it was determined that there is no reason to hear the aforesaid arguments; all the more so where the management company and the accompanying firm were not added as respondents to the petition.  On the merits of the argument as well, the court ruled that the appellant was unable to show that the tender that is the subject of the petition changes the state of affairs in such a way as to create a built-in conflict of interest, particularly in light of the respondent's explanations that there is no expectation of a change in the manner of operation of the management company and the accompanying firm.

The appellant's other argument on the level of the conflict of interest, as stated above, focused on the involvement of the lending firm and the management company, both at the stage of determining the tender provisions and at the stage of examining the proposals.  The appellant's argument regarding involvement in the design of the tender provisions was rejected by the trial court in the absence of a factual basis, in view of the respondent's clarifications that the contribution of the lending firm to the design of the tender was minor.

On the other hand, with regard to the involvement of the accompanying firm in the process of examining the proposals, the trial court found a certain difficulty, based on the fact that the market for lawyers in the field of municipal taxation is limited.  In the hearing that was held, it clarified in"The Respondent said that to the extent that the Court believes that it is not sufficient to blacken the details of the bidders or to reduce the involvement of the lending firm, the Respondent will agree that the lending firm will not take part in the examination of the proposals.  Indeed, the court was of the opinion that there is room to order that the lending firm not take part in the examination of the proposals.  "If only in order not to put him in a situation where there may be a conflict between an interest related to the performance of his job and another personal interest of his".

Previous part1...45
6...32Next part
Skip to content