As to the appellant's argument that there was room to determine Prerequisites of conflict of interest - The court noted that the tender includes provisions regarding a conflict of interest, and in this framework the tenders committee is even granted the authority to disqualify a bidder's proposal due to a conflict of interest (clause 100 of the tender). Given the aforesaid, the court ruled that the decision not to classify the following provisions"30 as a prerequisite is found in the discretion given to the authority, and there is no room to intervene in this.
- Quality scoring according to criteria - The trial court rejected the argument that unreasonable weight, in the framework of the quality score, was given to the size of the bidder (the number of lawyers in the firm) and the number of cases and proceedings it handled. The court was required to divide the score and noted that the appellant's grievance was directed against a total of only 15 points, out of the 65 points awarded for all the quality components combined; while the other quality components deal with the quality of pleadings and the management of legal proceedings (30 points), and an impression of the bidder based on interviews and recommendations (20 points). On the basis of the aforesaid, it was determined that the score given for the components of the quantity is relatively low. In any event, it was held, the criterion of the number of lawyers in the firm allows, at most, only 4 points (out of 65), and therefore there is no basis for the appellant's claim that this condition is intended to "tailor the tender" to the specifications of certain bidders.
At the same time, the argument that the quantitative data are not relevant to the quality of the bidder was rejected, while it was held that: "The number of proceedings conducted by the bidder attests to his experience and the scope of his activity in the relevant field, and the number of lawyers in the firm indicates the bidder's ability to cope with the work that will be transferred to him".
- Illegality of the tender terms due to a violation of the ethics laws - the District Court rejected the appellant's arguments that the tender provisions violate the ethics laws.
Firstand regarding the claims regarding the uniqueness of the legal profession (Article 20 Law Israel Bar Association) - The trial court reiterated that the functions and powers of the management company do not derive from the tender that is the subject of the petition, but rather from the management tender from 2016. At the same time, the argument on the merits of the matter was rejected, while it was held that although there is a possibility of transferring the handling of cases to the management company, this does not determine that the management company is entitled to take actions in the field of attorneys' practice, nor should such a possibility be read into the terms of the tender.