It is clear that the sentence "as if it were" cannot establish any proof against the defendant. Moreover, he clearly stated that "I do not know who erased it at such a level."
At most, this is a very general and highly amorphous hypothesis on the part of the computer supervisor Shai. In other words, it is quite possible that the files that were deleted or disappeared from the plaintiff's computers (if at all occurred in reality - and we highly doubt this), the deletion occurred under the responsibility of any of the possible factors in the plaintiff. Thus, for example, it is possible that this was a malfunction that occurred in the plaintiff's computers.
We will therefore conclude and note that the testimony of the computer supervisor Shai also did not help to prove the plaintiff's claims against the defendant.
Another comment, and regarding the defendant - during his testimony, the defendant was asked (for the first time) to open the e-mail box, which is located on his mobile phone, "in order to clear his name". The defendant refused. The plaintiff places great emphasis on this refusal, and notes that the refusal establishes an evidentiary presumption that acts in his obligation[38].
We found no substance in the claim, and it should be rejected.
First, from the procedural aspect, not every refusal to conduct an examination necessarily leads to the establishment of a presumption of the obligation of the refusal. Consideration must be given to the totality of the evidence presented before the court[39];
Second, the plaintiff herself admits that the defendant is not obligated to present his email box during the evidentiary hearing[40];
Third, there is no place for a party to allow the examination of his mobile device, suddenly during his testimony, in an irregular manner and without it being done in an appropriate manner, and without ensuring that his (general, and unrelated to the proceeding) privacy is indeed preserved. The National Labor Court's rulings even set out detailed guidelines regarding the examination of an employee's mobile phone as part of a legal proceeding, and which was done as part of the document disclosure process - and not in a sporadic manner "and on one foot" during the evidentiary hearing[41];