Caselaw

Class Action (Tel Aviv) 11278-10-19 Yehoshua Klein v. Oil Refineries Ltd. - part 123

January 13, 2026
Print

[....]

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        A., I am aware of this issue

(In detail, pp. 978-980).

  1. Grotto was asked about the effect of smoking on health and answered as follows:

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          What is the impact of smoking on public health?

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        At the level of public health, smoking is harmful to public health. 

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          Harmful to public health?

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        Yes

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          If I smoke, I'm harming my health. 

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        If you smoke you harm your own healthI mean...

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          Only my own, yes? of myself and also of those who have been exposed. 

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        Maybe also exposure, yes. 

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          Also to the exposure of those who were exposed to me, right?

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        True.

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          And this smoking the more I smoke the more I get hurt or does it not matter?

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        Look, it could be, I'll say it like this, I'll explain the matter, It is an event that has a statistical probability.  I mean, if you smoke basically one cigarette can cause one harm, but of course if you smoke 100 cigarettes then it increases the chance of more of some riskSo there's a connection between the quantity and the effect, not that he, I'm again, it's ultimately a specific event that happened at one point and it's a matter of probability. 

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          Obviously, so the more cigarettes I smoke, the more cigarettes per day and the longer I have, the greater my health risk.  Right?

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        Yes

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          And there's such a thing in medicine that they talk about the patient's years of smoking, a few boxes for a few years, right?

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        That's right, PERSON YEARS The so-called

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          PERSON YEARS.  My late father, who unfortunately died of lung cancer, had 75 years of smoking, which was 50 years and a box and a half a day.  Do you know that?

Previous part1...122123
124...200Next part