Q: Okay.
A: That's it..
Q: Ok. Now the article is in front of you. You said earlier that this article speaks and proves that free radicals are caused by chemicals in air pollution.
A: Yes.
Q: The article is in front of you. Direct us, where are chemicals even mentioned here in this article?? First of all, look at it. Let's start step by step. We have two steps. One, Where does it say chemicals?? And the next step will be Where it says that chemicals from air pollution raise radicals. So let's start, the first step, where does it say chemicals?
A: Please take a look at my review.
Q: No, no, in the article.
The Honorable Judge D. Chasdai: Mr. Shalita, they are talking about The article Right now.
Q: I won't look at the opinion, I'm asking you about the article.
The Honorable Judge D. Chasdai: Mr. Shalita, on the article at the moment, he relates, focuses and refers to the article, not to the opinion.
A: In the article, it may not be written. In the opinion, I wrote.
The Honorable Judge D. Chasdai: Forget the opinion, we don't ignore it, and it's in front of our eyes.
A: Yes.
The Honorable Judge D. Chasdai: But he's interrogating you right now about The article, so focus on the article, leave the review.
A: Yes, so about the article.
The Honorable Judge D. Chasdai: He asks about the article only, not your opinion, its dignity is in its place.
A: All right.
Q: Where in the article? Two steps forward with you. One, there is an article here Write Chemicals. And after you go through that step, if you find chemicals, I'll ask you Where does it say in this article that chemicals from air pollution raise radicals. So the first step is, where does it say chemicals?
A: Okay. He may not have written about it, but I have other articles. He refers to..
The Honorable Judge D. Chasdai: We are in this article.
A: He relates. all right So maybe he didn't write about it so I don't relate to it (pp. 155-157).
- Shlita was referred to page 21 of his opinion and to an article by Valkom, Morris and Cronin regarding "metal toxicity and oxidative stress". According to him, although he referred to the abstract of the article and read it in its entirety, he did not know what academic degrees the authors held, what their training and professional experience were. He also did not know what research methods they measured oxidative stress, and confirmed that their experiment concerned exposure to metals and took place in laboratory animals and laboratory conditions, and he did not know "... In what concentrations of metals did they throw the laboratory animals" (pp. 158-159).
- Shlita was referred to another article No. 2 mentioned on page 22 of his opinion, which was marked as exhibit M/7 regarding "free radicals, metals and oxidation in oxidative stress induced cancer", and he was asked and answered as follows:
Q: Please see the conclusions section of the article. Do you have the article?