A: 2011
Q: 2011. Before you got married, did you promise her a place to live and only a place to live?
A: No, I didn't promise anything, because I didn't even have a place to live and I asked my father to live in his house. And he told me okay, I got his consent that I would live with him, in the old house.
Q: I mean, you didn't promise her, as is customary in the sector, that when someone is going to get married, he says you have a residential apartment that will serve us as a residential apartment?
A: I didn't promise, I didn't promise her anything, because I don't have anything, I don't have anything to promise, I don't have a house, I don't have anything, the house is for my father, everything he took from my grandfather, I don't have anything. I'm a human being like that, I have to get married and take care of my future" (par. of December 16, 2024, pp. 2, 10-24).
- The woman's answers in her cross-examination give the impression that she does not respond clearly or consistently:
"Q: The claim of a promise in marriage in 2011, the current apartment was not yet built, the building was not built at all, so your claim for this reason is also not true, please confirm it
The Honorable Judge: I didn't understand the answer.
A: It wasn't built.
The Honorable Judge: It was not built.
Q: So there was no promise about this apartment, the current one
A: This apartment, yes
Q: Promise, I'm asking about a promise
The Honorable Judge: Wait, I didn't understand the answer. Is this apartment yes what? She said a lot of things
A: In this apartment, we saved money, we worked.
The Honorable Judge: But the question was about a promise made during the marriage in 2011. What does she say? Wait a minute, I don't hear the answer.
A: But this is my apartment. This is my apartment was mine. This apartment was mine. I was sitting in my apartment.
Honorable Judge: I am what?
A: I was sitting in my apartment
The Honorable Judge: Good.
Q: Now it's version 23 after the divorce, you never said that there was a promise in marriage to the current apartment that had not yet been born. This is the new apartment, we will get to it, I will ask you about it. So please confirm fairly, if you know that the current apartment was not at all a matter of promise in the first place, it was not in the marriage?