Caselaw

Criminal Case (Be’er Sheva) 29984-08-16 State of Israel v. Muhammad Zoabi - part 70

August 17, 2017
Print

Criminal Appeal The location documents that were filed show that the defendant was in Beit Kama on April 29, 2016, and from there he began a trip north that took about two hours until he reached Na'ura, where he did not deny that he refueled and there is confirmation about refueling on the said date (P/96 - Confirmation from a representative of the credit company regarding refueling at a gas station in Na'ura on April 29, 2016 at 15:06).

Driving data on Route 6

  1. A white Volkswagen car is registered in the name of the defendant's daughter, And this is a vehicle that is also used by the defendant (Bull' From the day 8.5.2017 pp' 313 Shaw' 13-27) And this is the suspicious vehicle that drove Hamel"VIII, And according to road data 6 (A/105) It can be seen that the vehicle passed on a driving route starting from the Sorek interchange at an hour 13:49, Through the Nesharim Interchange, Ben Shemen, Nachshonim, Magic, Horshim, Eyal, Nitzanei Oz and up to the Baka North interchange at 1 o'clock 14:28.

This data is well consistent with the cellular data about the defendant's travel route.

Security Cameras

  1. Shadi's statements correspond in terms of timing to footage taken from cameras in Beit Kama (A/68-A/70) where vehicles can be seen entering the station compound, Including a white van that belonged to Shadi, and Adi purchasing a bottle of water was recorded as part of the/71 (As Shadi described in his testimony), as well as the arrival of additional vehicles, including car C'Te & Car BMW As Shadi stated in his testimony (A/69-A/71).

It can be seen from the footage of the security cameras, in the discs submitted 69-71, as well as from the photographs submitted in P/72, from the videos, that the arrival times of Shadi's car and the other white vehicle were between 13:02 and 13:16, all on the said date of the incident, 29 April 2016.

These photographs support the schedules, the time, and the sequence of events described by Shadi.

In his statement of 17 July 2016 (Exhibit 187), Shadi (Exhibit 19) says that Adi arrived at a previous meeting in a white Passat vehicle, and later says that the vehicle came to him at Beit Kama and collected the ammunition, it was the same vehicle, the same color and of the same type: "I think that the vehicle that came to me at Beit Kama, which collected the ammunition, was the same vehicle, because it was the same color and the same type" (Exhibit 187 Q.  22-23).

Previous part1...6970
71...77Next part