The summary table of Shachar's coordination notice (P/146):
And the summary table in Shohat's second e-mail (P/132, Matrix proposal):
The schema of the components in the two summary tables reaches $449,440, as Shahar wrote in P/146. The amount indicated by Shochat in the concluding table in the second email (P/132) - $395,860, is obtained from the sum of the prices of all the servers, except for the sum of $53,850 attributed to the WBRS-OLM servers. The table relating to servers of this type was omitted, as mentioned above, from Shohat's proposal in the second email. This is the same type of server – the X3650 M3 servers – that Shohat's first email this afternoon (N/450) referred to.
As already noted above, Shohat's second email message (P/132) – in which the Matrix proposal – was not presented to Shochat during his interrogation with the Authority. In his testimony, Shochat did not have an explanation that the total amount of the offer corresponds to the total amount in Shachar's coordination notice (P/146) by subtracting the amount specified by Shachar as the price of one of the types of servers as stated above (p. 6885, s. 19 - p. 6886, s. 6; s. 18; p. 6887, s. 6-9; p. 6890, s. 14-23; p. 6762, s. 23-24; p. 6815, s. 22-29). At the same time, Shochat insisted in his testimony that the total amount of the Matrix proposal that he submitted to Kashnevsky was $395,860, as stated in the concluding line of P/132 (e.g., p. 6751, paras. 6-13; p. 6888, paras. 21-22; p. 6889, s. 20; p. 6890, paras. 11-12).
The accuser's position – so I understand it – is that Matrix's offer to Balam Oranim is not the offer that was attached to Shohat's second e-mail message (Exhibit 132) – which amounted to a sum of $395,860 – when it was alone. Instead, according to the accuser's position, Matrix's offer is a combination of N/450, Shohat's first email message in which a price quote was made for one of the types of servers, and P/132, Shohat's second email in which a price quote was made in relation to the other three types of servers (see paragraphs 984-990 and 1001-1002 for the accuser's summaries). In this way, Matrix's offer amounts to a total of $449,440 as requested by Shachar (P/146; more precisely: the total sum obtained from the combination of Shohat's two emails is $444,790, according to $8,155*6 (P/450) + $395,860 (P/132)). The accuser supported her position mainly by comparing the documents and by the fact that the sum of $395,860 is obtained from the price scheme of all types of servers, which, as Shahar noted in the coordination notice (P/146), while deducting the sum of $53,850 attributed to another type of servers in relation to which Shochat had earlier sent to Schnevsky the first email message (P/450) (the accuser found some support for her position in Shohat's words in his testimony, P. 6888, paras. 18-19 that he believes that he omitted the missing table in the second email he sent to Skanevsky (P/132) because he sent its configuration earlier in the first email (P/450); See also: p. 6748, paras. 14-15 for the price of $53,830 is the price given for the type of servers in question).