Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 31

December 10, 2023
Print

With regard to the decision on the application to amend the minutes, I will note and emphasize that the request for amendment was granted for the most part; with the exception of the court's reservations about certain amendments.  Admittedly, the respondent gave its consent to most of the amendments, including amendments that were rejected by the trial court.  However, the consent of the parties does not negate the court's discretion; in particular, where the requested amendments are in relation to the order of the hearing and the comments made by the court during the hearing.  One way or another, after examining the amendments that were requested and rejected by the trial court, I found that they did not change the result of the rejection of the appeal against the judgment.  In these circumstances, there is no room to intervene in the decision.

 

Regarding the decision on the request for additional details: The District Court heard the arguments of the parties in this matter (in a hearing held on January 1,2023), and at the end of the hearing was of the opinion that the additional details requested were not required for the definition of the dispute between the parties or for the purpose of deciding the petition.  I do not find room to interfere with the discretion of the trial court in this matter.

Conclusion

  1. I would suggest to my colleagues that we reject the appeal against the judgment, subject to the consent of the respondent detailed above in the paragraph ‎38. In the meantime, I would like to propose that we also reject the appeal against the interim decisions of the District Court, dated August 19,2022 and January 1,2023.

In view of the respondent's agreement to amend the tender, as detailed above, I will suggest that the appellant bear reduced legal expenses in the sum of ILS 15,000"VIII.

 

Judge

Justice D.  Barak-Erez:

  1. At the outset, I will note that I agree with my colleague, the judge J' Kosher that at the present stage, and taking into account the changes made in the tender provisions, the appeal should be dismissed on its merits.
  2. In these circumstances, the preliminary question, which concerns the possibility of filing a petition against the terms of the tender by a person who participated in it after the deadline for submitting the proposals, is superfluous on the practical level.  In any event, taking into account the arguments that were raised in this matter and my colleague's attitude to the issue, I agree with his position in principle regarding the difficulty in filing such a petition, even at a stage where the identity of the winner of the tender has not yet been known.  I would like to clarify my reason for this.
  3. As my colleague the judge noted Kosher, a deep-rooted rule is that it is not appropriate to file a petition based on the terms of the tender after the identity of the winner has become known - Both from the perspective of the delay laws and from the perspective of the preclude laws.  My colleague's judgment sharpens the reference to a situation in which the petition was submitted after the deadline for submitting the bids in a tender, but before the identity of the winner became known.  Indeed, there is a certain difference between these two situations, first and foremost in view of the fact that after the submission of the bids in the tender the identity of the winner is still unknown, and therefore the petition is still filed under certain conditions of uncertainty.  However, from the perspective of the implications for the tender owner, as well as for the participants in it, the similarity is not negligible.  The submission of a bid in the framework of a tender, instead of an appeal to the courts in a manner that challenges its terms, may be interpreted as acceptance of the rejection of claims raised at a previous stage.
  4. Delay - In the sense of the subjective delay, from the perspective of the good faith of the petitioner, there is a clear distinction between a situation in which the petition is submitted after the results of the tender have been known and a situation in which they are still unknown.  However, from the objective aspect of the delay, which is no less important, the postponement of the proceeding to the stage where the bids have already been submitted in the framework of the tender is problematic.  This means that if the arguments are accepted, the result may be a re-publication of the tender, which entails costs for both the tender owner and the participants.  Another dragging result is a delay in the timetable for the execution of the tender's object, works or the provision of services.  The application of estoppel to those who did not take legal action directed against the terms of the tender before the end of the deadline for submitting bids is important not only from a forward-looking perspective, but also from an anticipation of the future - In order to incentivize the participants in the tender to raise their claims on time.  It should be noted that even in a situation where the objections of those who are considering participating in the tender have been rejected, and there are several days between this date and the deadline for submitting the proposals, the filing of a petition is necessary.  As is well known, the length of time that a delay is formulated may vary depending on the type of case, and in tender matters, deadlines are of utmost importance (see: Dafna Barak-Erez Administrative Law Volume 4 - Procedural Administrative Law 375-360 (2017)).
  5. Prevention - Another way of presenting the matter is the recognition of a starting point where, as a rule, a person whose arguments regarding a tender were rejected and decided to participate in it without filing a petition accompanied by a request for appropriate temporary relief before the deadline for submitting the proposals, will be prevented from filing such a petition.  This is in view of the fact that, as stated, the submission of a bid in a tender without taking legal action beyond the deadline for submitting bids, may be interpreted as the completion of the participant in the tender with the rejection of his claims.  This is in accordance with the general considerations that apply to precluding the raising of claims against the terms of the tender when it was possible to do so at a previous stage (see: Dafna Barak-Erez Administrative Law Volume 3 - Economic Administrative Law 190-192 (2013)).

                                                                                      Judge

Previous part1...3031
32Next part
Skip to content