Caselaw

Labor Dispute (Haifa) 61090-02-25 The Israeli Center L.A. Reshet Ltd. – Guy Yanchik - part 12

November 5, 2026
Print

-           The plaintiff made do with very general arguments, and she did not prove at all that she had a "secret" client list;

-           The plaintiff also did not prove that the phone numbers of the plaintiff's customers were within the scope of the information that is unique to it;

-           The plaintiff also did not prove that this was information that could not be obtained from any other external source;

-           It was not proven by the plaintiff that the alleged confidentiality of the information gave it a business advantage over its competitors;

-           The plaintiff also did not prove that reasonable measures were taken to maintain his confidentiality of the same information.

  1. In light of the above, we conclude and determine as follows:

In the procedural aspect, in order to substantiate his claim against the plaintiff, the employee Tal Cohen did not ask the defendant to send him the contact details with the plaintiff's customers, but rather that he would send him the defendant's various chats on the WhatsApp software, in order to see what transactions Tal had made with the plaintiff's customers.  This is not a problematic act in any way, and as we have already noted above, the plaintiff has waived her claim against the employee Tal in the past;

On the factual side, the plaintiff did not specifically prove that the telephone numbers of the plaintiff's customers were transferred by the defendant to the employee Tal Cohen.  In any event, as a former employee of the plaintiff, the employee Tal Cohen was aware of the details of the engagement with the plaintiff's customers;

From the normative aspect, it has not been proven that this is a "trade secret".

III.5.  A fourth statistic that operates to fulfill the plaintiff's version and claims - the lack of proof of damage

  1. We will conclude the discussion with the following statement: Beyond all the conclusions we have reached so far, The plaintiff also did not prove that she suffered any damage regarding the defendant's alleged actions. Thus, for example, the plaintiff claimed that "After the theft of the information, the company began receiving reports from past customers and potential customers that they had received inquiries on behalf of Tal or entities on his behalf, using accurate information that could not be in his possession unless it was taken from the company's databases.  This information included details that were never provided to external parties"[102].  She also claimed that she had suffered millions of shekels in damage[103].
  2. Here, too, and similar to her conduct during the proceeding, the plaintiff did not bring any references or details. She did not specify who the customers allegedly received, when the conversations were held and with whom, or what was said in them.  Another claim that was not proven in this context by the plaintiff was regarding "The Direct Impact on Its Revenues" as a result of the defendant's actions[104].  All this, since not a single solid financial figure was presented, nor any references, such as financial statements or an accountant's opinion.
  3. When the owner Daniel was asked in her testimony why the plaintiff did not attach documents attesting to any decline in her income, including an economic opinion, she again did not provide a substantive response. The owner Daniel referred to the invoices that the plaintiff attached to her affidavits: "We attached dozens of invoices amounting to tens of thousands of shekels that attest to the way we collected the information, whether it was participation in conferences, or gifts we distributed at these conferences..."[105].
  4. However, and as we have already explained above, this is not relevant evidence in any way, and it is not possible to understand anything from the invoices - not with regard to the plaintiff's exact expenses in the past, and certainly not with regard to her future losses as a result of the acts attributed to the defendant[106]. Moreover, the plaintiff even admits in her summaries that this is only an "estimate" of her damages[107].
  5. Indeed, the plaintiff claimed in her summaries that she should be compensated with compensation without proof of damage, in accordance with the section 13 of the Commercial Torts Law (this is an expansion of the façade, which the defendant objected to)[108], as well as in light of the agreement signed between the parties. However, once we have determined that there is no defect or wrongdoing in the defendant's actions, there is no reason to award such compensation for his obligation.

III.6.  Another note before finishing

  1. In the section 15 The plaintiff petitioned for the following relief: "to obligate the defendant to return to the plaintiff the amount of commissions that were overpaid to him in the sum of 38,250, in light of the fact that the defendant did not close transactions on his own, and the plaintiff, through the company's CEO, was required to close all the actual transactions". The plaintiff did not specify this remedy at all during the proceeding, and in fact neglected it.
  2. Conclusion
  3. In conclusion - In light of all of the above, the lawsuit Reject in full.
  4. Expenses - For the reasons that will be detailed below, the expenses should be placed on the high side:

-           The plaintiff made serious and blatant accusations against the defendant, bordering on the criminal level, and which were not proven at all;

Previous part1...1112
13...18Next part
Skip to content