- As part of the preparations for the lawsuit that he filed against the plaintiff at the time, which was heard in this court, he asked for evidence regarding correspondence on WhatsApp that was conducted with customers, which attests to the fact that he did indeed recruit clients[70];
- To this end, he asked the defendant to send him correspondence on WhatsApp, which was found on the plaintiff's computers;
- Contrary to what is claimed in the affidavit of Director Tzachi, he never received files sent directly to him to any of his private emails, from the plaintiff's computers, but only files of the WhatsApp software, as stated above;
- However, in the end, he did not use the information given to him by the defendant[71];
- As for the defendant, he did not provide him with information about the plaintiff after he worked for it, other than the WhatsApp correspondence[72];
- He never competed with the plaintiff in business[73].
- Employee Tal's version was not contradicted at all in his testimony, during which he even stated that he did not enter the relevant folder (Google Drive) on the plaintiff's computers, which the plaintiff referred to during the proceeding[74]. He also reiterated his arguments raised in his affidavit, noting that "My goal was because I also sued the same company, my goal was to prove that they did indeed steal commissions from me for mutual customers that Guy and I had, and this is the only purpose for which I gathered and asked Guy to send me WhatsApp correspondence that would indeed testify that I did deal with those customers, other than that I have no interest and nothing"[75].
- The reliable and continuous version of the employee Tal is fully acceptable to us, and it is also consistent with the evidence submitted in the proceeding. This is a factual basis that is as far away as 'east from west' between what the plaintiff noted and described during the proceeding and what was actually proven. In any event, the cause of action was argued against the defendant and not against the employee Tal, against whom the plaintiff waived the claim against him.
- As for the defendant - In the preliminary hearing, and to the court's question, the defendant was asked and answered, as follows: "To the Tribunal's question as to why and why after the termination of the work for the plaintiff I sent Mr. Cohen files related to working for the plaintiff, I reply that Tal is a friend of mine and asked me, these are customers who were joint customers of ours and I just sent them to him and I didn't think and I am sure and know that Tal will do something, or open a business and compete with them, he is a friend and I sent. To the Tribunal's question as to whether Tal Cohen worked at this stage for the plaintiff, I answer in the negative, and he was fired two months before me."[76].
- The defendant further said: "Tal asked me to send correspondence with clients we had and I sent. I'm sure that if they bring the contents of the files, I'm sure it's not a matter of planning to open a company or steal information and pass it on"[77], and also "... (q) If they bring the content of the correspondence, it will be proven that there is nothing in them that has to do with the big words in the statement of claim "theft of a trade secret" and so on"[78].
- From the aforesaid it appears that the defendant admitted (in all honesty), already in the preliminary hearing, that he did send employee Tal correspondence from various groups on the WhatsApp software. This is a date after the termination of employee Tal's employment, but while the defendant is still working for the plaintiff. However, and as we will see below, these facts are completely different from those claimed by the plaintiff in the proceeding, andWe have before us neither a hacking action nor an action of erasure. More importantly - as we will see below, The information sent is also not a "trade secret" at all.
- In the context of the last conclusion above, which we will detail now, we emphasize that it has not been proven by the plaintiff that the information that was transferred by the defendant was "confidential" in any way. Later on, we will analyze the case law regarding "trade secret" and examine its application to correspondence on the WhatsApp network, and it appears that in the specific case, it is not at all information whose transfer harmed the plaintiff in any way.
- In any event, following what he said in the preliminary hearing, when the defendant was asked in his testimony why he denied in his statement of defense that he had transferred confidential material from the plaintiff's computers, but later admitted that he had transferred the WhatsApp correspondence to Oved Tal, he replied as follows:[79]:
"I didn't remember what happened in 2021 as soon as I received this statement of claim when it wasn't happening, I didn't remember what it was, I got a very general statement of claim like that, yes? I didn't remember that on 19 I sent an email, no, so I denied it, I didn't remember and then you showed me that I sent an email, so I went looking and really found out that I sent an email, right, I sent an email to Tal on that date which is indicated, right, at the time I wrote the statement of defense I didn't remember it."
- As a complement to these words, see also the defendant's words in the preliminary hearing: "When these questions were asked, did I send files, I didn't remember what happened before 4 For years and I don't have these files on my computer. What happened was that I was fired because I got cancer, of course, in those months from8/2021 Until February and March, I only dealt with my illness and didn't check what files existed"[80].
- We find nothing wrong with the defendant's answers and explanations in this matter. To be precise, it was the plaintiff who filed a very general statement of claim, without detailing the defendant's precise and alleged acts. See, for example, the following description in the statement of claim, below: "... The Ancient Defendant on the Day 19.10.2021, at 19:47 approximately, the defendant's business information"[81] (The reference was to the plaintiff, obviously). After a long time has passed, there is nothing wrong with the defendant stating such a general denial in the framework of his statement of defense, in response to such an amorphous claim and as it was raised against him. The defendant's honest confession at the preliminary hearing also works in his favor, and testifies to his good faith, and not the other way around.
- Proof of the correctness of the defendant's claims is also found in the evidence that the plaintiff submitted to the court file. As may be recalled, the plaintiff submitted photos and video, which she claimed were taken during the defendant's hacking of the plaintiff's computers. As for one photo, and the same applies to the video, we have already reached the conclusion detailed above, that they were taken from the email account of the employee Tal, and not of the defendant.
- However, the plaintiff submitted additional photographs, from which it can be clearly understood, that this is information sent from the defendant to the employee Tal, of "Chat WhatsApp With..."[82]. In other words, it is possible to reach the conclusion that At most, the defendant sent the employee Tal correspondence that was conducted on the WhatsApp software in various groups. This conclusion is supported by the affidavit of discovery of supplementary documents submitted by the defendant to the court file, to which he attached these correspondences[83].
- From the aforesaid it appears that the defendant committed an act completely different from that attributed to him by the plaintiff. Contrary to what is claimed by the plaintiff, these are not the files "... Phone, emails, contact details, their professional classification with CEOs, marketing managers, salespeople, which websites are active" (and as also claimed in the testimony of the CEO Daniel), and that they were stored in some obscure software, on the plaintiff's computers. However, that the defendant sent the employee Tal correspondence that was conducted in various WhatsApp groups, In order for the employee Tal to be able to prove his claims against the plaintiff, including the claim that he is entitled to commissions.
- The next question that must be discussed is whether we are dealing with correspondence that contains a "trade secret". In a preliminary note to this issue, we will reiterate that as part of the document disclosure proceeding that was conducted in the proceeding, the defendant submitted the files to the court file The Complete and the Complete of the various chats (conversations) that took place between him and the plaintiff's employees, including the CEO Daniel. Other chats include correspondence with the plaintiff's clients.
- The defendant also stated in the affidavit of discovery of documents, as follows: "Following the last pre-trial hearing, I searched again and was able to locate a copy of the email I sent to Tal Cohen on the date 19/10/2021 with the WhatsApp correspondence to which the plaintiff referred. I am honored to attach the email correspondence as well as the contents of the WhatsApp correspondence as appendices 1-13, for this affidavit"[84].
- Here are the names of the chats: "Appendix 1 (Email to Tal Cohen)"; "Appendix 2 (Chat with Oron - Kata Entrepreneurship)"; "Appendix 3 (Chat with the Strategy of the Expensive)" ; "Appendix 4 (Chat with Ben Kata - Kata Entrepreneurship)"; "Appendix 5 (Chat with Daniel - CEO)"; "Appendix 6 (Chat with the Center - the company's WhatsApp group)"; "Appendix 7 (Chat with the Center - Group of Company Updates)"; "Appendix 8 (Chat with Tal Cohen - a colleague at the company)"; "Appendix 9 (Chat with Milan - A. Ginnadi Company)"; "Appendix 10 (Chat with Mordechai - a colleague in the company)"; "Appendix 11 (Chat with Tal, Emanuel - a colleague in the company)"; "Appendix 12 (Chat with Tzachi Shoval - CEO of the company); "Appendix 13 (Chat with Shai - Senior Manager at the company)".
- Contrary to what is claimed in the plaintiff's summaries, the mere transfer of the information by the defendant is not sufficient in itself. On the other hand, we accept the defendant's argument in his summaries that Not every automatic provision of information becomes a tort of theft, and the existence of confidential business information must be positively proven in correspondence[85]. In the case before us, and as already noted, notwithstanding the fact that the defendant submitted, as aforesaid, the correspondence that he conducted on the WhatsApp software - whether in an individual or group setting; whether those that were conducted with the plaintiff's employees, or those that were conducted with the plaintiff's clients, The plaintiff's witnesses did not relate to the information submitted by the defendant, as part of their affidavits.
- During the evidentiary hearing, CEO Danielle even replied in her testimony that she had reviewed "Partially" in the defendant's documents[86], while the manager Tzachi, for his part, noted that he also did not really look at the defendant's documents: "No, he added some name 7000 Pages, I didn't delve into it"[87]. In addition to the above, The defendant was hardly questioned about these files during his testimony, nor about what was alleged in the affidavit of discovery of supplementary documents submitted by him.
- We are of the opinion that this is the place to apply the rule, according to which refraining from questioning a declarant of his affidavit can lead to the result that the declarant's version will be accepted. See the following: "... As a rule, the refusal of a party to make use of this important tool of cross-examination leaves the version of the witness who was not interrogated as a true version that has not been refuted, and is interpreted as the consent of the person who refrained from interrogation, to the state of affairs as presented in this version"[88].
- See also what is stated and claimed in the defendant's summaries, which we accept: "... The plaintiff did not even try to show that these WhatsApp correspondences contained any commercial information or trade secret, and this was sufficient to bring about the dismissal of her claim in its entirety, since insofar as there was information or a trade secret in them, the plaintiff could easily have pointed to it in the correspondence themselves, and since she chose not to do so, it is clear that she did not locate (and does not) such a thing in them"[89].
- On the plaintiff's part, in her summaries she argues as follows: "The defendant's attempt to dress up his act as "innocent WhatsApp correspondence" will not succeed: according to the testimony of the defendant and Mr. Cohen himself (the defense witness), these are correspondences with the company's customers, which bear their identity, the terms of the engagement with them and their contacts. This is the confidential business information himself, whatever his name may be"[90]. In the summaries of the reply, the plaintiff further claims that the defendant passed on information about her engagements with her clients[91].
- The claims must be rejected in their entirety. We will reiterate that the plaintiff's claims were concentrated in the 'computer hacking thesis' (a baseless and fictional version, which was not proven at all), and she did not discuss or relate at all in her affidavits to those correspondence that the defendant disclosed, with full transparency and with the aim of striving to investigate the truth. Therefore, this is a discussion that was conducted by us beyond necessity, since we are dealing with claims that were not made by the plaintiff in the first place. However, we will continue to note that a review of the files submitted by the defendant shows that these are not 'confidential' correspondence in any way.
- In the normative aspect, we should mention that the 5 The Commercial Torts Law, 57591999 (Hereinafter: "Commercial Torts Law") defines what a "trade secret" is, as follows: "'Trade Secret', 'Secret' - Business information of any kind, which is not in the public domain and cannot be legally disclosed easily by others, the confidentiality of which gives its owner a business advantage over its competitors, provided that the owner takes reasonable measures to maintain its confidentiality".
- In case law, a number of tests have been established for the purpose of determining whether certain information is a trade secret: the information must confer a commercial advantage on its owner[92]; The information must be confidential and not accessible to the public, or it is information that requires an investment of time, money and effort[93]; The savings in the investment should be taken into account for those who have been exposed to the trade secret[94]. It was also ruled that if we are dealing with general knowledge and professional skills acquired during the course of work, the public interest requires that the employee be able to use these as well as for one employer or as a self-employed person.
- On the other hand, things are different when it comes to special trade secrets that are typical of a specific business, the use of which by the employee may cause harm to the employer. With regard to the latter, the employer is entitled to protection[95]. It was also determined that the obligation to protect the employer's business secrets, not to exploit them for the needs of the employee or for the needs of others, and not to disclose them, is not contingent on the fulfillment of an explicit provision in the employment contract[96]. Also on the matter Check Point The National Labor Court famously ruled, that "Trade secret is not a magic word..."[97].
- From the general to the individual - In the case before us, we will reiterate that there is no and no proof on the part of the plaintiff that the correspondence in the WhatsApp software, which the defendant transferred to Oved Tal, includes her confidential or commercial information. The claim of the plaintiff's witnesses, which came up for the first time in their testimony, that these were the names and ostensibly 'secret' phones of the plaintiff's clients, should also be rejected. See, for example, the testimony of the manager Tzachi: "... Reaching the CEO of Sulam Yaakov is not something that is advertised on the Internet and reaching the owner of Sulam Yaakov or the marketing manager is not mobiles that are advertised on the Internet, it is their personal mobiles and getting to the mobiles of Eshel HaYarden Construction Company is not, by the way they are ultra-Orthodox, it is not something that is advertised anywhere"[98].
- We emphasize that not only is this a real expansion of the plaintiff's front - since it was not clearly and unequivocally stated in the affidavit of the manager Tzachi, but it was also not proven by him, and for example by means of objective testimony, of any of the plaintiff's clients. On the other hand, the defendant testified that there is "... Lists of clients with phone numbers, some of which we would also search for on the Internet, enter some real estate developer and find the phone and call not necessarily through the same table"[99]. This argument is fully accepted by us, and it was not contradicted by the plaintiff.
- In the matter Ben Baruch The National Labor Court ruled that a list of customers can fall within the scope of a trade secret and be considered a defensible interest, and this "Only in circumstances in which it will be proven that a special effort is required to obtain it, and in those cases it will be proven that there is some added value in receiving the list 'from the ready' "[100].
- The National Court added in the matter Golden Mountain, which has already been quoted above (and is even mentioned by the plaintiff herself in her summaries[101]), because "In many cases, the importance of a customer list does not stem from the identity of the customer, but from the terms of the transactions with him, the products he purchases, and the treatment he receives". Hence, a list of customers will be protected, only if it contains an advantage, trade secret, or other interest.
- In addition, in the case of Golden Mountain The National Court also determined a number of principles for the purpose of deciding whether it is a list of customers that deserves protection. This includes determining that the list of customers must be confidential; that it must be examined whether the new employer and the old employer compete for the same market segment or operate in the same industry, because if there is no competition between the two employers, then there is no commercial value to the list of customers.
- It was also determined that the extent of the employee's knowledge of the customers should also be taken into account (a distinction between a senior manager and a junior employee). In addition, a distinction should be made between an industry with only two customers and an industry with hundreds of thousands of customers; and the investment in creating the customer list and the investment savings for those to whom the trade secret is disclosed, must also be taken into account.
- In the case before us, the plaintiff did not meet this burden, even slightly, and none of the conditions required by the case law for the purpose of protecting the plaintiff's alleged list of customers were not proven by the plaintiff, And we determine that this is not a list of customers that is protected under the definition of "trade secret":
- The plaintiff did not submit to the court file an orderly list of her clients;