Caselaw

Labor Dispute (Haifa) 61090-02-25 The Israeli Center L.A. Reshet Ltd. – Guy Yanchik - part 10

November 5, 2026
Print

Both the laptop that the plaintiff provided me for work purposes from time to time, and the computer in my home (which I rarely used when the laptop on behalf of the plaintiff was with another salesperson), there was no remote access to the plaintiff's computers or databases, since the laptop I received from the plaintiff was used for the purposes of presenting the plaintiff's presentations to customers when meeting with them and for related email correspondence, and for that purpose only.

I did not breach my obligations to the plaintiff, I did not steal and delete business information, I did not breach the duty of confidentiality that I signed and I did not transfer information from the plaintiff's databases to a third party.  "

  1. The defendant further claimed that as part of my duties, the plaintiff provided me with a laptop, on which no access, full or partial, to the plaintiff's drive folders or to the plaintiff's databases was defined. In addition, he was never given access to the plaintiff's internal computer systems through this computer - not to all of the plaintiff's systems, nor to all of the plaintiff's general databases[53].
  2. Moreover, the defendant described that the plaintiff had three laptops for the salespeople, and he was among them. Sometimes one computer was out of use and a long time passed before a new computer was purchased.  During periods when there were more than three salespeople, they were forced to share the computers between them.  In addition, during times when he did not have the plaintiff's laptop, he used the plaintiff's permission on his personal computer at home for the purpose of writing work-related emails and for that only, without any access from him to the plaintiff's computers or databases[54].
  3. We emphasize that the defendant's version quoted above was not contradicted during his testimony, during which he testified that he was a person without technical knowledge and that "I don't understand computers"[55]. The defendant also noted that "...  I didn't have my own computer, it was completely wrong, I didn't have my laptop, I had a desktop computer stand in the office and there was a time when I did it 10 Supersalespeople 3 Laptops, this laptop, this MacBook, it's a simple computer, it just passed between the salespeople and the presentations, that's all, there were also cases where if I was in a meeting in the center and I was going back to the north I had to download the computer in the office, the laptop, because someone else is going to the meeting tomorrow..."[56].
  4. The defendant also testified, and regarding the dispute regarding "Google Drive", that he "... I don't know if it is, what is Google Drive, what is Google Drive, there was a table that Shai made and I had it on my computer and I would update material there"[57].  In any event, he emphasized that this table was not transmitted by him, to the employee Tal.  In our opinion, his claim in this matter was not refuted by the plaintiff at all, and we adopt it.
  5. The artisanal evidence submitted by the plaintiff - The plaintiff presented several photographs as well as a video (one), in order to substantiate her claims, regarding the defendant's alleged act of burglary. We will address them now.  One photograph was allegedly taken during the defendant's hacking operation on the plaintiff's computers, and it allegedly shows how the defendant sends information from his email to a Tal employee[58].  However, this is irrelevant evidence, since this particular picture[59], illustrates something completely different - This is an email sent by the employee Tal to the defendant, and not the other way around[60].
  6. The same applies to the video that was presented by the plaintiff, and which was allegedly filmed by the manager Tzachi at the very moments when the defendant carried out the hacking of the plaintiff's computers (hereinafter: "The video"). However, here too, this is irrelevant evidence, since the video does not show - and as claimed by the manager Tzachi - the "Guy's work environment(See again in the affidavit of Director Tzachi).  Repeated viewing of the video shows that This is a video that shows a review of one of the plaintiffs' (Principal Tzachi, apparently) which was also carried out in the email box of the employee Tal, and not of the defendant.
  7. In relation to this, when the person in charge of computing Shai was asked, "Don't you see the drive or the folders in the drive in the documentation here?", he admitted "Anonymous"[61]. On the other hand, the employee Tal claimed - and it was not hidden at all - that it was the plaintiff who infiltrated his email inbox in a way unknown to him, through access to the plaintiff's laptop computer, which he used during his work, and which was returned to her at the end of his employment.  See also the defendant's affidavit[62]: "In the video and photos that Daniel and Tzachi attached to their affidavits, you can see Tal's private Gmail inbox that was hacked by them or any of their employees and/or acquaintances.  There is no evidence that there was a remote login or my login to Guy's user environment, since the only thing we see in them is a criminal offense of breaking into Tal's private Gmail box and his email correspondence".
  8. The claims of the defendant and the employee Tal are correct and justified in our eyes, and they are consistent with the evidence submitted by the plaintiff herself, as stated above, and in the specific context - the reference to the video. As evidence, in the video you can see, as you may recall, a photograph of an email box, and among other things, an email was sent to "Tal Shlomo Cohen" (i.e., the employee Tal) by the Ministry of Health, with the "Green Pass"[63].
  9. Since there is nothing better than the sight of the eyes, we will turn to the following screenshot, from the video that the plaintiff submitted to the court file:

 

  1. And as a complement below it, there is also an email that the employee received from the National Insurance Institute, and see the following screenshot -
  2. When the owner Daniel was asked in her testimony, she did not contradict the above conclusion: "Q. You show an email that you claim was sent and it is not even controversial, that it was sent from Guy to Tal and I tell you that the photographs that you attached clearly show that they are from Tal's mailbox.  A. Okay, It could be"[64], and also that"Do you see that the sender's email is Tal? Okay, okay"[65].  When asked again, this time about the issue of the "Green Pass" that was just mentioned, she again did not provide any substantive answer[66].  Similarly, when Director Tzachi was referred to this issue, he confused stated that "It doesn't make sense, maybe it is, but I don't know, but it doesn't make sense..."[67], and also that"It could be, it could be, it could be..."[68].
  3. Moreover, in an attempt to explain the obvious problematic nature of the plaintiff's arguments, the owner Daniel argued as follows: "I don't know if the box that was open was Tal's box or Guy's box, I don't know how to say that, I know but that in the end the emails passed between the parties with valuable assets of the company, that's what I know, that's the bottom line"[69]. However, it was not proven, as stated above, that the plaintiff's "valuable assets" were transferred.  We will also reiterate that the plaintiff even deleted her claim against the employee Tal, and undertook not to file it again.
  4. In conclusion so far - In summary, the plaintiff did not prove the required data. First, it was not proven that the defendant had access to its computers on the relevant dates, since at the time of the incident he was no longer working in its service.  Second, it was not proven that he had technical access to the computers, since at that time his passwords had already been reset.  Third, the possibility of remote technical access was not proven.
  5. In addition, the little artisanal evidence submitted by the plaintiff - a number of photos and a video - does not corroborate her claims regarding the defendant's hacking of the computer. On the other hand, This evidence clearly and unequivocally shows that the plaintiff was the one who illegally and inappropriately penetrated the email box of the employee Tal.

III.4.  What is the employee Tal and the defendant? Yes Esau, and why there is nothing wrong with the defendant's actions

  1. What has been proven about the employee Tal - The testimonies and evidence show that the information transferred from the plaintiff's computers, by the defendant and by the employee Tal, was as described below.

As for employee Tal - employee Tal admitted in his affidavit as follows:

Previous part1...910
11...18Next part
Skip to content