After a number of sensitive files were opened, it was clear that those documents were being proactively transferred to external mail addresses. The files were sent to Guy's personal email address and to the mailing address of Tal, who also worked for the company in the past but is no longer employed there. These are two private addresses that are not connected to the company in any way and are not authorized to receive business information of any kind. The postal system clearly showed the movement of the files and their transfer directly from the company's internal drive to those private accounts.
At this point, I still didn't know that it was a theft that had already been carried out before. All I saw was that the computer turned on and Guy's user was opened remotely. On the screen, the company's folders appeared, and Guy quickly switched between different files. It was only while watching the actions on the screen that I realized what he was doing. Guy went through folder by folder, checked each document, and then opened his email account where messages sent two days earlier, on October 19,2021, appeared. As soon as I saw the mailbox open and all the files that had been sent to him by email two days earlier, I understood the picture. Guy didn't log in to steal now. He went in to make sure
That the theft he had already committed earlier was fully completed. He went through the same files on the computer, compared them to the files sent to him by email, and saw that everything had been copied. At that moment I understood for sure that the information had already been transferred to him on October 19,2021 , and I am glad that I see in front of his eyes that everything has been copied. I immediately took pictures and documented the screen in real time, with Guy operating the computer remotely and checking all the files he copied from the company one by one."
- We have before us a dramatic and extreme description of the act of copying important and extensive business information, which was allegedly carried out by the defendant remotely, within the plaintiff's computer systems. The problem is that the plaintiff did not prove the incident alleged by her, against the defendant, not on the day 19.10.2021 (the only date specified in the statement of claim), not on the day 21.10.2021 (an additional date, added later in the proceeding), or any other date. We determine that It was not proven at all that at one time or another the defendant broke into the plaintiff's computers and carried out the act of espionage and remote copying.
- There are also significant perplexities and many question marks regarding the plaintiff's version. We will detail below. First, we will note that apart from the actual execution of the action and the mention of the date 19.10.2021 In the statement of claim (and here is the date 21.10.2021 not mentioned at all), the plaintiff did not mention the act of espionage and copying itself - neither in the statement of claim nor in the preliminary hearing. A detailed version in this context was first mentioned only in the plaintiff's affidavits.
- Beyond that, The plaintiff did not prove at all that the defendant had any access to the plaintiff's computers, at the level of the dates. All this, While the alleged incident took place in the days 19.10.2021 and21.10.2021, on dates that are after the defendant's employment with the plaintiff, which ended in the same day 22.9.2021 - Also according to the plaintiff's own method[43]. In the preliminary hearing, the plaintiff's counsel did not even deny the date of termination of the work, and he noted that "... As for the dates themselves, I don't know how to pull out the date at the moment"[44].
- Moreover, The plaintiff did not prove at all that the defendant had any access to the plaintiff's computers, at the level of the general technical access. As for the defendant, he denied in his testimony that he ever connected to the plaintiff's computers from his home: "Q. Have you never connected to computers in the office from home? ... A. Just like that, it's absurd, it's completely delusional"[45]. The defendant's credible denial was not concealed, and it is fully accepted by us. On the other hand, the plaintiff did not prove, by means of reliable testimony, or objective evidence, that the defendant indeed had such a technical approach.
- Beyond that, we will further detail that the defendant signed a "travel form" at the end of his work, in the framework of which all the relevant equipment was returned to the plaintiff. and his passwords were reset to the plaintiff's computer systems. In his testimony, the computer supervisor Shai was referred to a form written and signed by him at the time of the defendant's termination of his employment with the plaintiff, where it was noted, inter alia, that the defendant had returned the plaintiff's equipment that he had in his possession, and that his passwords had even been changed[46]: "Changing passwords Email + Facebook + Systems CRM and so on."
- From the testimony of the computer supervisor Shai, it emerged that the defendant's passwords "of the emails" have indeed been replaced[47]. In other words, the defendant did not have a technical possibility to access the plaintiff's computers through his email during the month 10/2021, after finishing his work in a month 9/2021. Indeed, in the re-examination, Shai claimed that the defendant's password in a certain computer system, in the name of any deskwas not replaced. This is an argument that cannot be accepted, and must be rejected, since it was first raised in the cross-examination. In any event, the claim was not backed up by references, and there is no proof before us that the plaintiff's computer systems worked through the same alleged software.
- It should also be noted that The plaintiff did not prove at all that the defendant had any access to the plaintiff's computers, with regard to the remote technical access. Any argument it raised in this context[48], was claimed in vain and without technical proof or opinion in the field of computing. All this, despite the plaintiff clarifying that she intended to submit such an opinion.
- 0038. See, for example, the testimony of the owner, Daniel, who claimed in her testimony that the plaintiff's employees would remotely connect to the plaintiff's computers using two software: Anydesk andTeamviewer. However, it is puzzling why this claim was first raised in her testimony, and here too without a shred of proof, and for example - by means of objective evidence that shows that the plaintiff used/used these software at all. Here, too, the plaintiff is obligated not to submit a computerized opinion explaining how and in what manner the defendant may have infiltrated the plaintiff's computers, after the end of his employment.
- 039. In the preliminary hearing, the plaintiff's counsel noted as follows: "to the court's question as to how he had penetrated the plaintiff's computers if at this stage, allegedly and according to his claim, he did not have access to the plaintiff's computers I reply that I don't know how he did it"[49], and "To the court's question from where the plaintiff was exposed to those correspondences, I reply that it was open on his screen on the computer in the office. I am guessing and I am not an expert witness, and I need a more detailed explanation, I guess that he took control from a distance, and this is my estimate. To the Tribunal's question as to whether we intend to submit a computerized opinion, I answer yes" [50]. However, no such opinion was submitted, with all that this entails[51].
- As for the defendant, he claimed in his affidavit, as follows:[52]:
"I never hacked, logged in, or connected remotely to the computer in the plaintiff's office. I did not remotely open folders, files and documents on the plaintiff's computer in the office, including not through the computer that was provided to me by her at the beginning of my work, and I did not copy, send or delete any information from the plaintiff's computers or databases.