Lior: The person in charge of the shift said otherwise.
Life: We're out of proportion, we're not going to chase you, you're not answering. I have to chase you.? You complain about why you don't get a job that when you get a job you don't announce that you don't come
Roxanne: My announcement by email
Life: Respect us.
Roxanne: I haven't been taking shifts since September 17
Lior: That week, on September 21, I offer you vaccines. You informed me that you were flying without even announcing you, you didn't say when you would be back. I received your email on October 11, we weren't in the offices, it was a vacation.
Roxanne: I've been working for 3 years, I'm a good employee, I've never been on a single shift that I've complained about, they're taking me out of the call center
Life: She is the shift manager. Are you interested in working at the call center??
Maya: You will not receive compensation beyond what is set aside for you each month, we are under the supervision of the The salary can't be given just like that
Roxanne: I want to get what I deserve
- In the summary of the conversation, it is noted that on December 1, 2022, the plaintiff was sent a message on behalf of the defendant in which the plaintiff was asked to respond if she was interested in returning to work at the call center, and the plaintiff's reply was attached that she considers herself fired and asks the defendant not to contact her again:
"Hi Lior, good morning. I came to the conversation with the aim of giving you an opportunity to retract my dismissal of an advanced pregnancy, and after you urged me to hold the conversation in order to sort things out. Unfortunately, the conversation really did not meet my expectations. On the contrary, you made it clear that you have no willingness to compensate me for the months I sat at home without pay and for the damages I suffered and will be caused in the future as a result of my dismissal on September 17, 2022, while I was in advanced pregnancy. You hurled harsh accusations at me and shifted the responsibility to me. With all due respect, I don't see how it is possible to continue after such a conversation and I have no words to describe my disappointment with the attitude of an organization like MDA towards pregnant women. I ask you to stop contacting me, you have caused me very severe emotional and financial harm, and every request from you overwhelms me and increases my anxiety. In the spirit of the conversation between us, I will consider my next steps."
- In the summary of the conversation held by the defendant, it was written that the defendant rejects the plaintiff's claim that she was fired, that the plaintiff was the one who chose not to report to the shifts and was not interested in returning to work, despite the effort made to find her a variety of positions, and that she would be able to reintegrate into the defendant's work after her maternity leave:
- The employee was not fired at any stage, and she is certainly not fired. This argument is rejected, especially when the employee assigned herself to shifts throughout the period (which she did not attend for her reasons).
- We were sorry to hear that the employee was not interested in returning to work, especially when MDA made an effort and was offered a variety of alternative positions, even though she did not present certificates attesting to medical restrictions.
- At this stage, we leave the door open for the employee, and of course she is welcome to integrate into the work. As long as she does not integrate into the work, she will have nothing but to complain about herself.
- The evidence before us shows that the defendant was willing to return the plaintiff to work at the call center and to return the plaintiff to work after the maternity leave, but the plaintiff refused to return to work without receiving financial compensation for the two months in which she was not placed.
It was not proven that the plaintiff had low outputs
- After reviewing the evidence, we are not persuaded that the defendant was able to show that there was a substantive reason why she stopped placing the plaintiff in shifts at the video call center, and we are not persuaded that the plaintiff had low outputs or that the plaintiff's outputs were a consideration in the decision not to place her in the video center.
- The only evidence presented by the defendant in this context was a WhatsApp message sent by the shift supervisor Eti to the call center manager, Sigal, during the plaintiff's last shift on September 17, 2022, in which Eti wrote to Sigal that the plaintiff made only 36 calls: "Roxanne made only 36 calls, 9 minutes of calls, she really takes the time, everything"
- From this WhatsApp message, it is not possible to learn about the plaintiff's outputs at the call center, nor even about the output of the other samples at the call center. The defendant did not present any support for Sigal's version in the affidavit that the average number of calls to an employee at the call center was 50-60 calls. These are data that are supposed to be in the defendant's possession, and therefore it is presumed that if she had data to support her version that the plaintiff had low outputs, she would have presented them in the proceeding.
- In her cross-examination, Sigal was asked if she could show how many calls a regular employee makes at the call center and she gave an evasive answer: "I don't know, it's things we had, I had one, I'm not comfortable with the word, that we saw online, Dashbrod, beautiful. When we saw online, what was who, but I didn't have anything..." (p. 7 of the transcript, lines 1-3).
- In addition, an examination of the message that Eti sent to Sigal during that shift shows that the message was sent at 20:45, whereas in the plaintiff's attendance report it is stated that the shift ended at 23:00 (Appendix 7 to Dori's affidavit). Hence, it is impossible to know whether the figure of 36 calls at 20:45 attests to the number of calls made by the plaintiff on the shift. We will add that the correspondence between Eti and Sigal is from a shift that took place after Sigal had already informed Lior not to assign the plaintiff to shifts at the call center, and therefore the evidentiary weight that should be attributed to this message as an informative and objective report is low.
- The defendant also did not present any evidence that Sigal raised any claim against the plaintiff in connection with the alleged low outputs, and Sigal also did not declare that she spoke with the plaintiff on this issue during the plaintiff's work at the hotline.
- A review of the transcript of the conversation that Sigal had with the plaintiff on November 15, 2022, shows that the criticism directed by Sigal to the plaintiff did not include the issue of outputs even once.
- Similarly, in the summary of the conversation that Dori and Lior had with the plaintiff on November 29, 2022, nothing was mentioned about the plaintiff's low outputs, and it was written that on September 10, 2022, Sigal asked not to assign the plaintiff "due to disciplinary problems."
- In fact, Dori testified in his cross-examination that the plaintiff is a good employee: "She is a good employee, she is not an employee that I would like to get rid of. " (p. 32 of the transcript at line 15).
- After reviewing the correspondence attached by the parties, we did not find a single note relating to the plaintiff's work ethic, and therefore we reject the defendant's version in paragraph 14 of the statement of defense that the plaintiff's outputs were "significantly lower than expected (the work of the call centers at this call center was monitored and the number and length of calls they made were monitored)."
- Similarly, we did not find any evidence in support of Sigal's claim that the plaintiff had created 'demoralization' among the employees, because this claim was also made in vain and without any evidence or testimony in support of this, and as stated, Sigal also did not say anything in this matter to the plaintiff in real time.
- As for the dispute surrounding the plaintiff's complaint about the air conditioner at the video center during the last shift - as it appears from Eti's WhatsApp message to Sigal on September 17, 2022, out of the three air conditioners that were placed in the tent, two did not operate during the same shift: "There are 3 air conditioners, 1 worker, the one above us, the other 2 do not exhale any air, turn on but do not exhale air."
- In this regard, we found contradictions in the testimony of Sigal, who claimed that there were four air conditioners in the tent (p. 2 of the transcript at line 27), even though Eti's statement indicates that there were only three. In addition, we found that her testimony on this subject was not coherent, since on the one hand, Sigal claimed in a conversation with the plaintiff that she felt sorry for her because she had to work in extreme heat, but on the other hand she testified that it was cold in the center and that she herself wore fleece: "I wore brass because it was cold in these air conditioners, in August and September, yes. (p. 3 of the transcript in line 23).
It was not proven that the plaintiff refused other tasks in bad faith
- According to the defendant's version, she offered her a number of employment alternatives, which the plaintiff refused without justification and in bad faith (p. 48.1 of the statement of defense).
- Dori testified in his cross-examination that the plaintiff did not want to work in the jobs offered to her (p. 22 of the transcript at line 34). He further testified: "So I tell you that we offered her an infinite number of jobs and she had almost endless work, but she chose not to come" (p. 23 of the transcript 3-4).
- When Dori described the plaintiff's approach in relation to the options offered to her, he testified: "She wants to do the minimum in order to get the maximum" (p. 32 of the transcript at line 26). He later testified that the plaintiff did not want to accept any of the options that were given to her: "She did not want to be placed because she did not want to be placed, she did not want to be placed in any of the options that were given to her" (p. 19 of the transcript, lines 17-19).
- He also testified that the plaintiff took the pregnancy and turned it into a profession: "This lady, this lady took her pregnancy, and turned it into a profession, and turned this desire into a profession, sorry, no, I really mean it. But she made it a matter of getting paid for not working." (p. 27 of the transcript, lines 31-34).
- As will be clarified below, after reviewing the totality of the evidence, we have reached the conclusion that the version presented by the defendant in the statement of defense and in Dori's testimony regarding the alternatives that were allegedly offered to the plaintiff is not supported by the evidence.
The defendant demanded a commitment of six months as a condition for going to an instructor course
- The defendant claimed that the plaintiff was offered to go to an instructor course and that the plaintiff refused to do so in bad faith.
- As appears from the evidence in the case, the defendant did not offer the plaintiff to go to an instructor course at all, but it was the plaintiff who initiated a request to Lior regarding an instructor course that she had heard about from another employee and was interested in the possibility of going to it, at a time when she was working regularly at the video center.
- The correspondence between the plaintiff and Lior indicates that the plaintiff contacted Lior on her own initiative on September 8, 2022, with a request to go to an instructor course after the plaintiff heard from another employee that an instructor course had been opened: "Now Rowan told me that there is an instructor course that opened in Pat on Monday! I can join it. " (Transcript of the correspondence attached to Dori's affidavit at p. 65).
- As the plaintiff testified in her cross-examination, and this was not concealed, on the eve of the opening of the course, the defendant demanded that she sign a commitment to work as an instructor for six months from the date of the end of the course. The plaintiff, who was already in her seventh month of pregnancy at that time, testified that she was not prepared for such an undertaking (pp. 2-3 of the transcript). The plaintiff testified: "I was required to commit to a position of six months, yes."
- In addition, the plaintiff testified that when she spoke to Lior about the course a week before the start of the course, Lior did not tell her anything about the commitment required for six months (p. 3 of the transcript in lines 1-4): "I spoke to Lior about the course instructors a week before itopened, I think she should have informed me of this commitment on the day I spoke to her about the course, it is not a way the day before suddenly to put something on me that I need herto commit, I all wanted to work hours in order to get a salary. "
- The plaintiff wrote to Lior on September 11, 2022, sharing with her the difficulty of committing to six months at this stage of the pregnancy and asking to stay in focus: "A small question, I suddenly thought of a commitment for six months, but is it going to converge with maternity leave, etc.? I don't really know when I'll be back. And later she wrote: "I've thought about it a lot and I've also talked to my husband and I don't feel comfortable committing to anything right now after the birth. I don't know what will happen and how it will be and I prefer to leave all the options open to me. If it's problematic I'll completely understand and just continue on my way with samples until the birth. (p. 65 of the transcript of the correspondence that was attached to Dori's affidavit).
- When Dori was asked in his cross-examination why he did not accept the plaintiff's refusal to commit to six months when she is seven months pregnant, he replied: "She apparently receives counseling, and then she says, no, I'm not interested, I'm not coming, I'm not interested in signing a six-month commitment to work for an instructor course, okay. So if you're not interested in committing to the other half, what commitment do you have to the organization at all? You're not committed to six months. You're probably going to give birth soon, God willing, okay? And you say I'm not ready to commit, so what are we talking about? And I'm glad you're not stopping me." (p. 20 of the transcript, lines 6-11).
- In his cross-examination, Dori also addressed in the same critical tone the plaintiff's request to postpone her admission to the ambulance drivers' system in light of the pregnancy: "And then she gets the opportunity to drive and she doesn't want to. And she gets the option of instruction and she doesn't want (p. 19 of the transcript, lines 40-41).
- When Dori was asked if he knew that the plaintiff was requesting shifts at the video center and not being assigned to her, he replied in the negative (p. 24 of the transcript at line 26).
- From the evidence and testimonies it appears that the defendant did not show understanding of the condition of the plaintiff, who was seven months pregnant, or the connection between her refusal to commit to work for six months in an instructional position close to the birth of her first child. The defendant did not present evidence in support of her claim that the plaintiff assigned herself to shifts that she did not attend because she did not want to, did not present the assignments that the plaintiff submitted for shifts during the period, and as stated above, she refrained from summoning Lior, who was responsible for the plaintiff's assignments, to testify.
The defendant rejected the plaintiff's request to work as a defibrillator instructor
- The defendant claimed that the plaintiff, who underwent a short dedicated training on a defibrillator on July 12, 2022, rejected the offer to serve as a defibrillator instructor for no reason. It should be noted that here, too, the daily designated training that the plaintiff underwent was not done as an attempt to offer the plaintiff an alternative position, since this is the training that the plaintiff underwent even before she moved to the call center, and as it appears from the evidence, it was the defendant who decided not to assign the plaintiff.
- The defendant claimed in this regard in paragraph 13 of the statement of defense that: "The plaintiff for her reasons refrained from applying for and assigning to shifts as a defibrillator instructor, and in fact did not perform a single shift under the guidance of a defibrillator." Later, the defendant argued in paragraph 44.4 of the statement of defense regarding the work as a defibrillator instructor: "The fact that the plaintiff chose not to specify at all that she was trained as a defibrillator instructor and was given the opportunity to be assigned as a defibrillator instructor – two possibilities that the plaintiff thwarted and rejected without any justifiable reason, testifies to the plaintiff's lack of good faith."
- As will be clarified below, the evidence in the case shows that the plaintiff was the one who approached the defendant twice with a request to be assigned to this position, but was not assigned.
- Thus, it appears that on July 21, 2022, the plaintiff wrote to the person in charge of the defibrillators named Harel and asked to register for the trainings: "When does it start, how do I sign up for the trainings and everything... I did the training and since then I have not heard from anyone about it. Harel replied: "I am now working on the placements of this for the month of August. " (Appendix 13 to the plaintiff's affidavit).
- After she did not receive a response from Harel, the plaintiff contacted her once again to try to get a placement as a defibrillator instructor. This request was made on September 1, 2022, and this time the plaintiff contacted another person in charge named Itai, who replied on September 8, 2022, that her assignment to the position was 'less relevant': "Hi Roxanne, I checked with the space and understood that you are intended to expand your role to driving so that it is less relevant to us with great success. " (Appendix 14 to the plaintiff's affidavit).
- We would like to clarify that the plaintiff's requests to be placed as a defibrillator instructor were made during the period when she worked at the call center, and hence the defendant's version that it was an alternative job offer is contradicted by the evidence. The evidence shows that there is no substance to the defendant's claim that the plaintiff thwarted the possibility of being placed as a defibrillator instructor, and the evidence shows that it was the defendant who rejected this possibility.
- Before concluding, we note that we are unable to accept the defendant's argument in paragraph 16 of the statement of defense that the plaintiff's placement in shifts at the video center was not the plaintiff's "regular job", and this should be viewed as a short-term attempt that was unsuccessful. This argument is inconsistent with paragraph 8 of the statement of defense, from which it appears that the plaintiff was recruited to work in the COVID-19 system, which included sampling, vaccinations, and the operation of the call centers. Therefore, COVID-19 tests at the video center were part of the work in the COVID-19 system to which the plaintiff was recruited about two years earlier.
- Similarly, we are unable to accept the defendant's argument in paragraph 8.3 of the summaries that during the period in which the plaintiff worked shifts at the video center she performed shifts in other places, and this is a new version that contradicts both the plaintiff's version and the defendant's version in the statement of defense and her affidavits.
- It should be noted that although the plaintiff's attendance reports mention codes of various sites where the sampling shifts were allegedly carried out during the relevant period, Dori confirmed in his cross-examination that the codes listed in the reports have no significance and that they could stem from a typing error by the employee who typed the hours: "If she typed the wrong code or the wrong website, it is very difficult to identify it in the end. It was not done because it was really a matter. " (p. 34 of the transcript, lines 32-33). We will add that according to the plaintiff's coherent testimony, which was not concealed, since the last time she went to the video call center, she performed shifts only at the call center: "I don't remember that I also worked as a corona sample. That he wasn't on video during my work at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, I don't remember anything like that. (p. 18 of the transcript, lines 3-4).
- Therefore, the defendant's later version that the plaintiff performed sampling tasks in various locations during the period of her work at the video center is rejected. In addition, the defendant's version that the plaintiff in bad faith refused alternative tasks that were offered to her is rejected.
The defendant's conduct after the birth does not attest to the continuation of the employment relationship
- The defendant claimed that the plaintiff was not fired and that the employment relationship between the parties continued throughout the maternity leave and even afterwards.
- In support of this, the defendant attached a report by the plaintiff to MDA on December 14, 2022, regarding the birth of her son and a 'New Family Supplement' form entitleing her to a gift, and the plaintiff's signature about two weeks later on an appendix extending her employment with the defendant until September 7, 2023.
- With regard to the 'New Addition to the Family' form that entitles her to a gift, we note that the defendant did not present any evidence that the plaintiff was given a birth gift that was given to each mother, in a manner that is consistent with the plaintiff's version that she did not receive such a gift. Dori admitted in his cross-examination that contrary to the defendant's version on this matter, the plaintiff did not receive a gift in honor of the birth from the defendant: "She did not receive the gift. This gift, we have a problem with this matter. (p. 34 of the transcript, lines 1-3).
- The plaintiff claimed that the documents she signed did not indicate the continuation of the employment relationship and that she signed them in order to receive maternity pay. According to the plaintiff, the defendant is trying to hold on to her signatures in order to indicate that the employment relationship continued, but this is an attempt to create a semblance of an employment relationship, since the plaintiff announced that she considered herself to be fired even before the date on which she went on maternity leave.
- A review of the appendix signed by the plaintiff shows that this is an appendix to extend a period of employment for nine months from January 2023 to July 2023, in a manner that is inconsistent with the defendant's version that the plaintiff was employed on a quarterly contract. The defendant also did not explain in what position the plaintiff was defined as an 'employee' during this period.
- In these circumstances, we did not find that the plaintiff's signatures on documents sent to her should be considered to indicate that the employment relationship continued, or to contradict her consistent and coherent version that she had made it clear to the defendant that she considered herself dismissed in light of the defendant's refusal to pay for the two months in which she was not assigned to shifts.
- A review of the report of the periods of employment attached by the plaintiff shows that MDA reported the plaintiff as an employee until the date of her maternity leave in December 2022, despite the fact that the account was finalized in November 2023 (Appendix 17 to the plaintiff's affidavit).
- The evidence shows that the defendant unilaterally decided to continue to issue the plaintiff pay slips during the maternity leave, as well as to make pension contributions during this period, but we found no support for the fact that the employment relationship actually continued. Therefore, we find that we accept the plaintiff's version that in fact the employment relationship ended on the date on which the plaintiff announced that she considered herself to be dismissed, and we are unable to accept the defendant's version that the employment relationship between the parties continued throughout and after the maternity leave.
The plaintiff legally resigned from her dismissal
- In order to classify the manner in which the employment relationship between the parties ended as dismissal or resignation, we must decide whether the plaintiff's refusal to return to work at the video center amounts to resignation, or whether it is a dismissal as claimed by the plaintiff.
- After examining the entire evidentiary basis and the sequence of events detailed in detail above, we have reached the conclusion that after the plaintiff was not assigned to shifts at the video center for two months, the defendant suggested that the plaintiff return to shifts at the call center on November 15, 2022.
- The plaintiff refused to do so, and therefore it is not possible to determine as a legal determination that the defendant fired the plaintiff. The plaintiff even testified that she refused to return to the video center before she was paid her salary for the two months in which she was not placed, and as a result of the refusal she realized that she was being fired: "True, I wanted them to pay me the salary, which caused his loss and as a result of the fact that they did not agree, so I understood that it was dismissal... (p. 10 of the transcript, lines 1-2).
- In accordance with case law, an employee cannot unilaterally turn the employer's conduct into dismissal by declaring it (Discussion (National) 32/3-58 Broadcasting Authority - Meir Eshel, PDA 4 (1) 298 (1973)). It was further held that even if the employer did not dismiss the employee, he is entitled to resign, and in the appropriate circumstances this will be deemed to be a resignation under the law of dismissal ( National Labor Court (National) 3/3-18 Noah Benzilovich v. "Ata" Textile Company Ltd. (PDA 2 41 (1970)). Hence, an employee who is a party to an employment relationship cannot impose an intention of dismissal on the employer if the employer did not have such an intention in the first place.
- We are unable to accept the plaintiff's claim that she 'understood' that the defendant fired her after refusing to pay her wages for the two months in which she was not assigned to shifts, while the plaintiff was the one who rejected the offer to return to work. We did not find that the plaintiff was able to point to a clear and unequivocal act on the part of the defendant that expresses an intention to fire her or to bring the employment relationship to an end.
- However, we found that the termination of the plaintiff's placement at the video center significantly harmed the plaintiff during the pregnancy and her salary. The defendant's decision to return the plaintiff to shifts at the video center two months later, a week before the birth, while presenting her with a fait accompli that she must waive two months' wages, amounts to a deterioration of conditions because she was required to give up her economic rights during this sensitive
- The determination of whether an employment relationship ended with dismissal or resignation is a legal determination derived from the totality of the facts. In accordance with the ruling of the National Labor Court, an employee's claim that he was fired does not obligate the court to accept the legal classification proposed by either of the parties, and therefore the court has the authority to determine that an employee resigned and then examine whether the resignation amounts to dismissal (Labor Appeal (National) 24649-10-14 Liran Lahiani - Finestone Ltd. (January 10, 2016) (Labor Appeal (National) 584/08 Anonymous - Anonymous (June 29, 2011).
- On the basis of the totality of the evidence in the case, we determine that the circumstances of the termination of the employment relationship between the parties should be regarded as the resignation of the plaintiff in law, dismissed under section 11(a) of the Severance Pay Law, 5723-1963, and that the date on which she refused Sigal's offer on November 15, 2022 to return to work should be regarded as the date of termination of the employment relationship.
Prohibition of Harm to the Scope of Work and Income in the Women's Employment Law
- Section 9A of the Women's Employment Law, entitled 'Prohibition of Harm to the Scope of Work or Income', states: "An employer shall not harm the scope of the job or the income of an employee whose dismissal is restricted under section 9, during the period in which such restriction applies, except with a permit from the Minister of Industry, Trade and Labor, and the Minister shall not permit such injury if in his opinion it is in connection with the reason for which that restriction applies. "
- In the explanatory notes of the bill, it is explained that section 9A is intended to prevent the dispute on the question of whether harming the scope of the job or the income of a pregnant employee is dismissal (Women's Employment Bill (Amendment No. 14) (Prohibition of Harming the Scope of Employment), 5757-1997 , 346 (May 27, 1997):
"The Women's Employment Law, 5714-1954 (hereinafter – the Law), prohibits, in section 9(a), an employer from dismissing an employee who is pregnant and has not yet gone on maternity leave, unless the Minister of Labor and Social Affairs has given permission to do so. The said permit will not be granted if the dismissal is, in the opinion of the Minister, in connection with pregnancy.