Caselaw

Labor Dispute (Tel Aviv) 20818-06-23 Roxanne Hassid – Magen David Adom Association in Israel - part 2

November 9, 2026
Print

12-34-56-78 Chekhov v. State of Israel, P.D. 51 (2)The Proceeding and the Witnesses in the Case

  1. On June 8, 2023, the plaintiff filed the claim with the Labor Court.
  2. The plaintiff submitted an affidavit of the main witness and the defendant submitted two affidavits: an affidavit of Ms. Sigal Levy, the director of the video call center (hereinafter – Sigal) and an affidavit of Mr. Dori Haim, the manager of the district (hereinafter – Dori).

Summary of the plaintiff's arguments in the statement of claim:

  1. The plaintiff claims that she began her career at MDA when she was a high school student, trained as a first aid provider and volunteered for 3 years until she was drafted into the army. After her discharge from the army, she returned to MDA to volunteer and underwent a paramedic course and later began the process of being hired as an ambulance driver, but on the recommendation of the gynecologist, she asked to postpone her employment as an ambulance driver due to her pregnancy.
  2. The plaintiff began working on September 1, 2020, like Corona, through a manpower company, and was subsequently  hired to work for the defendant in June 2021.
  3. The director of the video call center where she worked did not like her pregnancy, so on September 10, 2022, the director of the call center ordered that she no longer  be assigned to shifts.
  4. The plaintiff, who did not know about it, continued to request a shift assignment . The plaintiff was assigned to another  shift on the 17th. 9.2022, after which she was no longer assigned.
  5. The defendant did not provide the plaintiff with any explanation for the termination of her work at the video center, and the alternative position that was offered to her to return to work as a warehouse worker in nursing homes did not match her medical condition in an advanced pregnancy.
  6. The plaintiff submitted a medical certificate dated October 6, 2022 with a recommendation not to employ her as a vaccinator in nursing homes, and about a month later, on November 6, 2022, the defendant demanded that she present a certificate from an occupational doctor.
  7. On November 15, 2022, the plaintiff was offered to return to her work at the video call center, and in a conversation with her, she found out that her work had been stopped on the orders of the director of the video center due to her pregnancy, after she complained that it was hot in the tent where the video center operated.
  8. The plaintiff conditioned her return to the video center on payment for the two months in which she was not assigned to shifts, but the defendant refused, and thus in effect signed her dismissal, and therefore she should be considered as having been fired on September 17, 2022.

The main arguments of the defendant in the statement of defense

  1. The plaintiff was hired into the Corona Division as an employee on a personal contract of varying scope for work that included sampling, vaccinations, and the operation of call centers.
  2. On July 11, 2022, the plaintiff announced her pregnancy, and on July 27, 2022, she requested to delay the expansion of her position to the ambulance driver to which she was recommended, claiming that she was not interested in physical work during her pregnancy.
  3. Due to the significant decrease in sampling and in an attempt to find employment for the plaintiff, the plaintiff was placed on August 3, 2022, at the video center that operated during the pandemic.
  4. After a short time, it became clear that the plaintiff often gets up from her seat, takes long breaks without informing the supervisor, and that as a result, her work output is significantly lower than expected. In addition, the plaintiff often shared the complaints with the other employees in a way that clouded the work environment.
  5. In this situation, on September 10, 2022, the director of the video call center  requested that the plaintiff no longer  be assigned to shifts at the call center.
  6. The plaintiff was given another opportunity on September 17, 2022, but problems arose on this shift as well, when the plaintiff made only 36 calls per shift, while the average was 50.
  7. The defendant offered the plaintiff additional employment alternatives, such as integration into the training system, but on the eve of the opening of the course, the plaintiff withdrew her agreement to participate in the course. Similarly, she rejected an offer to integrate into the vaccines in a nursing home and sent a medical certificate recommending reducing exposure to the at-risk population.
  8. Although the defendant believed that there was no substance to the plaintiff's claims, the defendant informed the plaintiff on November 9, 2022 that it had been decided to allow her to return to the video call center system.
  9. As a result, a conversation was held with the call center manager on November 15, 2022, in which the plaintiff conditioned her return on payment of wages for the two months in which she was not assigned to shifts at the video center.
  10. On November 29, 2022, the plaintiff was summoned to a conversation in which she was explained that there was no basis for her demand to receive financial compensation and that she could return to work at the video center the next day or present an appropriate medical certificate.
  11. The plaintiff, who claims she was fired in September 2022, filled  out a "New Family Supplement" form after giving birth, signed an appendix to extend an employment agreement until September 7, 2023, and enjoyed a   provident fund during the period of maternity leave.
  12. On July 13, 2023, the District Secretary contacted the plaintiff regarding the date of her return to work, and later it was made clear to her that she was not being fired, but after she insisted on the claim of dismissal, she was given a settlement.

Discussion and Decision

Previous part12
3...17Next part
Skip to content