After reviewing all the evidence in the case and hearing the parties' testimonies, we reached the conclusion that the defendant did not fire the plaintiff, even though she acted unlawfully when she stopped assigning the plaintiff to shifts at the call center when she was pregnant, and therefore she should be considered as having resigned legally dismissed.
Below we will detail the reasons for this.
The plaintiff was transferred to the video center due to her pregnancy
- The plaintiff began working like Corona in June 2020, and worked in the defendant's Corona unit for about two years before becoming pregnant.
- In July 2022, the plaintiff informed the person in charge of shift assignments, Lior Peri Matuk (hereinafter – Lior), that she was pregnant.
- On July 27, 2022, the plaintiff informed Lior by email that on the doctor's recommendation she was requesting to move to a job that did not involve exposure to patients due to her pregnancy, and asked her to check whether she could be transferred to another position in a way that would not affect her salary:
"Hi Lior, what's up? I wanted to consult with you about something. I know that expanding my role to a driver and it will probably only happen when I get back from maternity leave because it's relatively hard physical work and heavy stuff etc. and my doctor is not so much in favor of it, even in the samples she is already urging me to stop because being in contact with corona patients all day is not recommended. The catch is that I have to work as much as possible now that I have a normal maternity allowance (this is calculated based on the average salary of the last 3 months). Even if you stay in the samples I don't have enough hours there, here is today for example Shani didn't put me and probably won't tomorrow either. In short, I'm blessed and I'm dealing with it all day long and I'm worried about it and it's not healthy for me at all. Is there any other work I can do until I go on maternity leave for another 4 months? I'll take anything that isn't too physical, office work, schedules, security, secretaries, training (if it's enough hours) really everything. (Appendix 4 to Dori's affidavit at p. 61).
- The physical effort involved in the plaintiff's work, such as vaccination, can be learned from the employment contract signed with the plaintiff on May 31, 2021, in which it was noted that although the work itself is not physical, the job involves physical effort of standing for a long time with protective equipment, activity in conditions of extreme heat and harsh environmental working conditions: "It may be necessary to climb and descend stairs" and "there may be situations in which the sampler will stand on his feet for a long time while he is protected", "It is possible to operate in heavy heat conditions when operating in non-air-conditioned areas for a long time under protection. " (Appendix 1 to the plaintiff's affidavit).
- Three days after the plaintiff updated Lior by email about the medical recommendation, the plaintiff moved to work remotely performing COVID-19 tests at the video call center.
- The call center operated throughout the week and made it possible to remotely supervise the performance of home COVID-19 tests in front of a camera, while the patient is at home and an MDA sampler supervises the process on the other side of the screen in a way that prevents exposure to patients.
- The evidence in the case indicates that the plaintiff's transfer to the video center was done with the involvement of MDA's human resources officer, Shani Daniels (hereinafter – Shani).
- The plaintiff testified that Shani was the one who recommended that she be transferred to the video center where she would not be exposed to COVID-19 patients and would not be required to stand on her feet for many hours (pp. 16-17 of the transcript): "This was the job I was doing during my job during those months, and this was the position that Shani Daniels suggested I move to. When I'm honest, I was very good at the regular samples, in the work I did before the video, and she recommended that I move there, so as not to be exposed to people with COVID-19, so as not to stand on my feet for many hours. She offered me this position, I didn't even ask for it. "
- Similarly, the director of the video call center, Sigal, also stated in paragraph 8 of the affidavit that the plaintiff was transferred to her at the call center in coordination with Human Resources, and also testified that she knew that the plaintiff was pregnant (p. 3 of the transcript at line 11).
- In view of the above, we find to reject the defendant's version that the plaintiff was transferred to the video center due to a significant decrease in the samples, and to accept the plaintiff's version that she was transferred to the video center after she announced her pregnancy.
The director of the call center ordered that the plaintiff be stopped for shifts at the video center
- As appears from the evidence in the case, the plaintiff asked Lior for assignments to shifts at the video call center continuously throughout the period in which she worked at the call center, from the beginning of August to the middle of September 2022 (Appendix 4 to Dori's affidavit at pp. 64-65).
- Sigal stated that she was the one who asked Lior on September 10, 2022, not to assign the plaintiff to work at the video center anymore due to problems in the plaintiff's conduct, which included taking long breaks, complaints about working conditions that demoralized other employees, and complaints that it was hot in her tent and that she had difficulty prolonging the meeting (paragraphs 10-15 of the affidavit).
- Sigal further stated that on September 11, 2022, Lior informed her that she had spoken with the plaintiff on the phone, and according to Sigal's version, Lior asked her to give the plaintiff another chance (paragraph 16 of the affidavit).
- An examination of the correspondence between the plaintiff and Lior shows that on September 11, 2022, Lior informed the plaintiff that she was assigned to the Saturday shift on September 17, 2022: "There is a malfunction in the application, you will not see the Shabbat assignment for now, but you will know that you are assigned to this Shabbat. " (p. 65 of Dori's affidavit).
- According to the plaintiff's version that was not concealed, Lior asked her to report for the shift on Saturday, September 17, 2022 due to a hole in the system and told her that it would no longer be possible to assign her to shifts: "I was asked if I could fill a hole created in the assignment and come to the Saturday shift on September 17, 2022, I answered in the affirmative. On Saturday 17.09.22 I arrived at the shift and everything was as usual, I thought I had been returned to my position to the site but it was not the case, the next day on Sunday 18.09.22 I entered the app again and saw that I had not been assigned (again despite availability) and called to find out what was happening, in the call again I was told that they would not be able to assign me and that they would check what could be done with me. " (Appendix 10 to the plaintiff's affidavit).
- The plaintiff's last shift at the hotline was on Saturday, September 17, 2022, when the plaintiff was seven months pregnant, and Sigal was not present at this shift.
- Sigal stated that during the plaintiff's last shift on Saturday, September 17, 2022, there was a shift supervisor named Eti, who reported to Sigal on WhatsApp during the shift that the plaintiff was 'not doing anything'. As a result, and against the background of the previous complaints, Sigal informed Lior to stop assigning the plaintiff to shifts at the video call center (paragraph 16 of the affidavit).
- In her testimony, Sigal claimed that the plaintiff could have been assigned to other tasks in the defendant: "I explained to you even before there were other tasks in the space, there are other tasks. She can be assigned to other tasks. She can be assigned to other jobs. (p. 9 of the transcript, lines 12-13).
- When Sigal was asked in her cross-examination whether she had contacted the Human Resources Department in order to check whether it was possible to stop the plaintiff's placement at the call center, Sigal replied in the negative (p. 8 of the transcript at line 31).
- From the aforesaid, it appears that the termination of the plaintiff's placement in the video call center was done without consulting with the defendant's human resources, and even without Sigal having a conversation with the plaintiff regarding the complaints against her, before she ordered the termination of her placement at the call center.
- The plaintiff stated that only in retrospect did she learn that Sigal had given an order not to assign her to shifts anymore due to circumstances related to her pregnancy.
- In support of this, the plaintiff attached a transcript of a conversation she had with Sigal and Lior on November 15, 2022. We will clarify at this point that the conversation took place under the guidance of two human resources departments after two months in which the plaintiff was not assigned to any shift, and Sigal was asked to inform the plaintiff that she could immediately return to shift work at the call center.
- In the transcript of the conversation dated November 15, 2022, Sigal tells the plaintiff that it was difficult for her to see that it was hot for her and that it was difficult for her to sit because of the pregnancy, and that because of this she asked to be brought to her by someone else, 'someone who is not hot, does not hurt and is not good for him' (Appendix 9 to the affidavit at pp. 4-5, emphases added (R.S.B)):
The plaintiff: OK. Oh... I'm just like... First of all I don't understand why it really took so long. I was home for two and a half months and begged to go back to work and as if I didn't quite understand why from the next day as if everything had just changed. Like I work three Years...