12-34-56-78 Chekhov v. State of Israel, PD 51(2)
The apartment in xxx
- The plaintiff claims that the residential apartment in xxx is a joint property by virtue of a "specific intention of jointness, " reliance, and proven investment, and that the parties renovated it, lived in it, and transferred significant funds over the years for the mortgage. She adds that she left the apartment only out of real concern for her life and the minor's life due to the defendant's violence, and that he should not be allowed to benefit from his actions.
- The defendant, on the other hand, claims that the apartment is an external and separate property belonging solely to him, since it was purchased by him on the 7th. 2016 before marriage and introduction, priced at 1,150,000 ₪. The defendant notes that he raised the capital for the purchase independently (200,000 ILS equity, a loan from his parents totaling 300,000 ILS, and a mortgage in his name alone of 650,000 NIS), and that the parties lived there for a short period of at most a year and a half before living in a rental outside the apartment.
Balancing pension and social rights
- The plaintiff seeks an unequal balance of "70% in favor of the plaintiff and 30% in favor of the defendant" in all rights and savings from the marriage period, alongside balancing income gaps. She argues that this is justified due to the "severe and extreme violence" inflicted on her by the defendant, which severely impaired her earning capacity and even caused an outbreak of "acute arthritis" due to the stress she was subjected to.
- The defendant argues, on the other hand, that only an equal balancing (at a rate of "50/50") should be made of the social and pension rights accumulated from the date of marriage (00.00.2016) until the agreed separation date (10). 2023). He opposes unequal distribution or the use of a wage capacity distribution mechanism, arguing that the plaintiff did not sacrifice anything for his career but chose not to work for convenience. In his view, the plaintiff did not prove in a medical opinion her claims regarding arthritis or the causal connection to the alleged violence.
The debt to the caregiver Dr. K.
- The plaintiff claims that the debt to the caregiver is a personal debt of the defendant that cannot be balanced, as it arose from "personal care for the defendant" and is not a joint debt, and that the defendant's father committed to bear it. The defendant claims that the debt, which remains at 238,200 ILS, is a balanced joint debt resulting from treatment the plaintiff saw as couples therapy and was actively involved in. He adds that there is no evidence of his father's commitment to pay it and that the father is not a party to the proceeding.
Discussion and ruling