Caselaw

Claims after the settlement of litigation (Jerusalem) 47839-07-23 A.B. v. R.B. - part 3

October 8, 2026
Print

Specific sharing of an apartment in xxx

  1. The starting point in our case is that the apartment in xxx is an external asset to assets that must be balanced between the parties. Section 5(a)(1) of the Property Relations Law excludes assets that belonged to the spouse before the marriage as well as assets received as gifts during the marriage.  These assets have been referred to in case law as "external assets" (see: Civil Appeal 4151/99 Brill v. Brill, PD 55(4) 709).  Therefore, the fact that the apartment was purchased by the defendant before the marriage means that it is an external asset, excluded from the mass of common assets, unless a specific intention to share is proven under general law.
  2. The plaintiff claims a "specific partnership" in the apartment, in which the rights are registered in the defendant's name. The precedent on this matter is described in the ruling of Hon.  Judge Y. Wilner in CA 5620/24 Anonymous v. Anonymous [Nevo] [30.6.2025]:

The specific joint ownership doctrine applies to spouses subject to the Property Relations Law and stipulates that joint rights can be recognized between them regarding a specific property, based on general law, which should be interpreted broadly in light of the characteristics of the "partnership arising from marital life." This doctrine developed in case law based on a contractual structure, in which the question mainly examines whether the couple's behavior during their shared life indicates the formation of an agreement that the rights in the property are jointly owned by both.  Granting validity to such an agreement is based on general law and is also consistent with the law concerning sections 1-2 of the Property Relations Law and Section 8 of the Real Estate Law.  Given that this is a property rights sharing agreement, inferred from the couple's behavior, it is difficult to attribute to them a "sophisticated" agreement, which includes, for example, an unequal division of rights in the property; Rather, as a rule, we are dealing with an equal sharing agreement, which aligns with the characteristics of a "partnership arising from married life."

Previous part123
4...9Next part
Skip to content