Caselaw

Claims after the settlement of litigation (Jerusalem) 47839-07-23 A.B. v. R.B. - part 4

October 8, 2026
Print

See also: CA 1398/11 Anonymous v. Anonymous [Nevo] [published in databases] (26.12.2012)] (hereinafter: CA 1398/11); CA 10734/06 Anonymous v. Anonymous [Nevo] [published in databases] (14.3.2007); Civil Appeal 7687/04 Sasson v. Sasson, Net(5) 569 (16.2.2005); Civil Appeal 5939/04 Ploni v. Plonit, Net(1) 655 (8.9.2004); Civil Appeal 8672/00 Abu Rumi v. Abu Rumi, No(6) 175 (27.8.2002); Civil Appeal 1915/91 Yaakobi v. Yaakobi, 49(3) 529 (13.8.1995); and many others.

  1. Therefore, excluding the apartment from resource balancing is not the final word. Case law recognizes, as stated, the possibility of creating specific joint ownership in an external property under general law, provided that the claimant proves "something additional" beyond the mere existence of the marriage.  Among the considerations that can be examined: the spouse's investments in the property, participation in construction or improvement, taking joint loans, representations and promises, reliance, the manner of economic management regarding the property, and the parties' living circumstances.
  2. In CA 1398/11 [Nevo], Honorable Judge Amit (as he was then titled) detailed parameters to be considered when considering a claim of specific joint ownership of an external asset:

"Without making definitive rulings, I will list below several parameters that must be taken into account in our discussion on whether to recognize a specific joint ownership of the residential apartment:

( - ) Whether the apartment was brought by one of the spouses into the marriage ...  Or was it purchased by one of the spouses after the marriage. 

( - ) Whether the apartment was received during the marriage by virtue of inheritance or gift, in which case, in my opinion, a greater degree of proof is required...

( - ) Whether the other spouse also owns a residential apartment or other external asset that he brought to his marriage and which remains registered in his name.

( - ) The length of the period during which the apartment was registered in the name of one spouse and the number of years the couple lived in the apartment (the shorter the period, the greater the required proof of joint ownership).

Previous part1234
5...9Next part
Skip to content