( - ) The length of the marriage until its dissolution or until divorce (the shorter the marriage period, the greater the required proof of joint ownership).
( - ) Whether a loan was taken for which a lien/mortgage was registered on the apartment, and which was paid over the years jointly by the spouses.
( - ) Massive renovation or significant building addition funded by both spouses.
( - ) Behavior of the parties - a general atmosphere of cooperation and joint effort.
( - ) Additional specific circumstances such as creating a representation to the other spouse.
It is understood that the parameters listed above-some of which "pull" in opposite directions-are not an exhaustive list, and each case will be discussed on its own merits."
- In a further hearing, the High Court of Justice 8537/18 Anonymous v. Haifa Regional Rabbinical Court [Nevo] (24.6.21) Honorable President Hayut divided the parameters examined into two main categories: considerations related to the property for which the intention to share is alleged (such as: whether it was purchased or received as a gift or inheritance, and if it was purchased, who financed the purchase; whether the property came into the possession of its owner before or during the marriage); the financial and financial conduct of the spouses regarding the property, For example, whether they took a joint mortgage to finance the purchase or construction; whether the spouse claiming joint ownership made financial investments in the property; whether both spouses (whether in money or labor) participated in significant renovations carried out, planning, or construction of the property; promises or active representations by the registered spouse towards the other; and regarding the couple's residence - the length of time they lived in the property), and considerations related to the spouses themselves (such as: the duration of their marriage; the nature of their relationship, and whether even a partial degree of harmony existed "even if life was not a 'rose garden'"); the financial conduct of the spouses and whether there was an "atmosphere of sharing" between them; whether the spouse claiming joint ownership has another external asset that remains registered in their name).
(See section 32 of the judgment. Regarding the principles of the specific joint ownership doctrine, see also sections 26-37 of the judgment).
- The question of whether a specific intention to share in a particular external asset was proven is a matter of fact, and each case must be examined on its own merits and according to its circumstances (see: CA 2948/07 Anonymous v. Anonymous [Nevo] [published in databases] (18.4.2007)).
- It should be added that regarding the couple's residence, which is considered the "highlight" of marital co-ownership, it has long been established that the burden of proof to prove joint ownership in it is lighter compared to other assets. However, this applies only as long as that "additional factor" indicates an intention to share in that property exists.
- The plaintiff presented evidence and testimonies about her move to xxx while resigning from her job in Jerusalem, relying on the defendant's representations that the apartment would serve as their shared home. Additionally, she and her parents inspected the apartment before the wedding, found serious defects in the sewage system, and led a thorough renovation through a contractor on behalf of her family who offered a significant discount. The plaintiff's sisters even came to physically assist with organizing the apartment, cleaning it, and preparing it for living.
- The plaintiff proved that the renovation loan taken from the defendant's mother was repaid by standing order from the couple's joint account. She attached bank statements showing that while the defendant was unemployed for about half a year, she financed the mortgage and transferred funds from her personal account to the joint account for loan and mortgage repayments. According to her, the monthly mortgage payments were made over the years from the joint account and from shared resources.
- The plaintiff's father supported her version and testified that he helped the parties refinance the mortgage loan, which saved them mortgage repayments amounting to over 100,000 ₪. Additionally, the father testified that he voluntarily led and managed the TAMA 38 process in the building for about two years with the intention of improving the apartment, and was even appointed as a member of the "Building Committee on TAMA 38" in August 2018.
- The plaintiff presented evidence, including email correspondence and a lease agreement, proving her involvement in finding tenants and in the day-to-day management of the apartment rental after the parties moved to Jerusalem. The lease agreement was drawn up with the assistance of her father, who works in real estate, and the rent received from the property was deposited over the years directly into the joint bank's bond.
- The plaintiff emphasized that no prenuptial agreement was signed between the parties for the property, and they held a "housewarming" in which the apartment was presented as their shared home. She also referred to the defendant's own confessions in his interrogation, according to which he immediately deposited it into his personal account since high school with the intention of establishing a condominium without a prenuptial agreement.
- Throughout the proceedings, the plaintiff claimed that married life included good periods and that there was harmony and an atmosphere of sharing between them. In her affidavit, the plaintiff stated that "we had good times between violent attacks, there was good harmony at home, " and that "the mindset during our married years was that the apartment was shared and belonged to both of us." She added that "throughout our marriage, I relied on the fact that sometimes there were beautiful times between us."
- In her testimony in court, the plaintiff rejected the claim that they never had a good relationship and clarified: "It is not correct to say there were no harmonious relationships. We married out of love, and what kept the relationship going was indeed love and faith in change." When asked when harmony prevailed, she replied that it was during "most of the years of marriage, " and that the relationship began to deteriorate "roughly in the last year." She described their shared life as mixed, during which there were "beautiful times between this and that violence."
- In her closing arguments, the plaintiff reiterated the claim that it was a "marital relationship out of love and a desire for a shared life that was broken due to the defendant's outbursts of anger." She emphasized that "the harmony was not broken due to natural erosion, but because of his own violence" that led to her escape to the shelter, and that he should not be allowed to build on this to claim a lack of sharing. In her view, this is a couple who lived "a shared life and the birth of a son, without a prenuptial agreement while living in a shared house, treating it as joint and declaring it joint."
- However, elsewhere, the plaintiff presented a different version, according to which the parties' relationship was poor, violent, and full of suffering from beginning to end, contradicting her claim of harmonious relations:
- In section 8 of the statement of claim, the plaintiff categorically claimed that she "suffered a life of suffering and bitterness from the defendant, who treated her and their minor son with physical and mental violence." Furthermore, in section 11 of the statement of claim, the plaintiff stated that "during most of the parties' marriage, the plaintiff suffered greatly from the defendant, who treated her with severe physical and verbal violence, including threats to use a gun." In section 4 of the affidavit, she added that throughout "the entire period of our marriage, " she and her son experienced physical, mental, and economic abuse from the defendant.
- In her testimony dated 4.3. 2024 At the hearing on the request to seize half of the rights in the apartment (as also quoted in the Registrar's decision), the plaintiff admitted that the violence began immediately at the start of the marriage, with "verbal violence two weeks after [the wedding] and physical violence starting on the honeymoon." These statements led the Registrar to determine that the plaintiff's own version paints a picture that "most of the time the parties' relationship was in a bad state."
- At the beginning of the lawsuit's closing arguments, the plaintiff defined the period of the parties' shared life as "a marriage that is short in time but difficult in its content."
- In addition, statements written by the plaintiff in a parallel proceeding between the parties regarding their son are added -
"Throughout the years of the parties' marriage, the plaintiff suffered greatly from the defendant, who behaved towards her with severe physical and verbal violence, including threats to use a gun against the plaintiff and the minor. The plaintiff suffered severe violent outbursts from the defendant towards her, frequently... " (Section 10 of the statement of claim in the post-settlement claims case 44626-07-23).