And later, in section 13: "About a month after the parties married, the plaintiff found herself in a cycle of violence that did not cease until she left the house. "
- The conclusion from the above is that the marriage period, at least for the most part, was not good, and it cannot be said that there was an "atmosphere of sharing" between the parties.
- This is not a long shared life, only about six years. The apartment was purchased by the defendant before the marriage, the equity for the purchase was his, the mortgage was registered in his name, and his mother took a loan to help him with the purchase.
- On the other hand, the plaintiff had her own apartment, for which she took out a mortgage, which she paid in installments from her bank account. The plaintiff claims that this is an external asset that should not be balanced between the parties, and the defendant does not dispute this.
- The parties lived in the apartment in xxx for a relatively short period and left it to live near the plaintiff's parents in Jerusalem. The parties do disagree on the reasons for the move - while the plaintiff claims that the excessive interference of the defendant's parents in their lives caused him to flare up violently and therefore forced them to leave, the defendant claims that the departure was due to the plaintiff's desire to live near her parents and because the parties in xxx did not have a community that suited their lifestyle. In any case, this is a short period of residence in the apartment that does not create the necessary connection to establish specific partnership.
- The renovation carried out near the entrance to the apartment was minor and intended for the entrance only and nothing beyond that, so it is not a significant investment, and the assistance provided by the plaintiff's father regarding mortgage refinancing and advancing TAMA procedures does not exceed family assistance from a father-in-law to improve the couple's life and is not based on sharing his daughter in his son-in-law's apartment.
- The mortgage payments for the apartment, as well as the loan repayment the defendant received from his mother for the purchase, were paid from the defendant's account, to which he added the plaintiff after the marriage. The main mortgage payments and loan repayment were made from the defendant's earnings, just as the mortgage payments for the plaintiff's apartment in... were paid by her from her bank account, into which her earnings were deposited. Therefore, the parties' conduct should not be seen as agreement or intention to jointly pay the mortgage payments and loan repayments.
- From all the above, it follows that the plaintiff did not prove an "intention to share" on the part of the defendant in the apartment xxx, nor was it proven that there is "anything additional" under which the plaintiff should be granted ownership rights in the defendant's apartment. Therefore, her claim on this matter must be dismissed. This is an external asset that is not included in the asset pool for which resource balancing was made.
The claim for resource equalization at a ratio of 30%-70% in favor of the plaintiff
- An unequal distribution in resource balancing is possible only when special circumstances justify it, at the request of one spouse, and in an exceptional and proportionate manner; the mere existence of an economic gap or a general sense of inequality is not sufficient.
- Section 5 of the Property Relations Law states that upon the dissolution of the marriage, each spouse is entitled to half the value of all the spouses' assets, subject to the exceptions detailed in the law. Therefore, equal division is the rule, while deviation from it requires special justification. Section 8 of the law grants the court the authority to deviate from the rule only when there are special circumstances justifying it.
See on this matter the High Court of Justice 8463/19 Plonit v. The Great Rabbinical Court in Jerusalem [Nevo] (24.10.2022).
- The application of Section 8 is not routine. The law does not define a closed list of special circumstances, so it is necessary to examine the full range of the couple's circumstances and the result created by the equitable division. Among the considerations recognized in case law: significant gaps in earning capacity or financial capabilities, future assets, career assets, gaps in joint effort, fulfillment of financial obligations within the marriage, as well as bad faith conduct regarding disclosure or management of property. However, the authority should be exercised sparingly and in special cases so that the exception does not become a rule.
Family Appeal (Central District) 55308-09-22 D.H. v. A.H. [Nevo] (12.7.2023)