High Court of Justice 4178/04 Ploni v. Rabbinical Court of Appeals, Sab(1) 235 (13.12.2006)
Family Appeal (Central District) 23025-08-21 A. A v. D. A [Nevo] (28.4.2022)
- Examining the conditions is not merely technical but requires a cumulative assessment of economic and personal life circumstances and the question of whether an equal division would lead in the specific case to an unjust outcome.
- Section 8(2) allows it to be determined that the equalization of asset values, in whole or in part, will not be done half-and-half, but according to a different ratio, taking into account, among other things, future assets and the earning capacity of each spouse. Therefore, significant gaps in earning capacity may be a relevant consideration for an unequal division, but they do not create automatic eligibility for such a division. The purpose of using this section is to prevent an unequal and unjust outcome and to allow substantial equal opportunities for the weaker spouse.
Family Appeal (Central District) 23025-08-21 A. A v. D. A [Nevo] (28.4.2022)
Family Appeal (Haifa District) 5420-10-21 A v. B [Nevo] (18.4.2022)
- The plaintiff petitions thecourt to exercise its authority under Section 8(2) of the Property Relations Law and to determine that the balancing of the parties' resources and the division of pension and social rights will be done at a ratio of 70% in favor ofthe defendant and 30% in favor of the defendant. This demand is based on her claims regarding the severe and extreme physical and psychological violence the defendant inflicted on her throughout the marriage, which forced her and their minor son to flee to a shelter for women victims of violence.
- According to the plaintiff, the consequences of the defendant's violent behavior and the severe pressure she was under had a direct physical cost, causing an outbreak of "acute arthritis" in her body. This is a chronic disease requiring constant treatment throughout her life with various medications, which severely impaired her functioning and led to a drastic decline in her earning capacity in the past and future.
- The plaintiff further notes that she sacrificed her career for the family unit when she stopped working after the birth of their son to care for him, and afterwards was unable to return to her previous salary level (about 6,000 NIS) due to her physical and mental difficulties. On the other hand, the defendant developed his career in high-tech, completed a master's degree, and today earns "tens of thousands of shekels" per month, creating a huge income gap between the two during their marriage.
- As legal basis for her claims, the plaintiff refers to the Supreme Court ruling in CA 7272/10 Plonit v. Ploni [Nevo], which ruled that in cases of severe violence, an unequal balance must be imposed, since the violence directly harms the economic functioning of the injured spouse. She adds as supporting evidence the fact that since her escape to the shelter, she is almost unable to support herself and is forced to rely on financial assistance from her family members.
- The defendant replied that there is no factual or legal basis to apply the exception set forth in Section 8 of the Property Relations Law, since the plaintiff's claims of violence were not proven in a criminal court, her false complaints were closed, and she uses them only as a tactical manipulative tool. He refers to case law that Section 8 should not be used as a punitive tool or as damages for any fault in marriage, and deviation from equal balance should be done sparingly and only in extreme cases.
- Regarding the plaintiff's medical condition, the defendant notes that the diagnosis of "acute arthritis" is a medical matter requiring the submission of a medical opinion, which was neither submitted nor requested by the plaintiff. He refers to the plaintiff's own admission in cross-examination, according to which she has no medical documents or expert opinions linking her arthritis to the defendant's alleged behavior.
- Regarding career assets and earning gaps, the defendant claims that both parties entered into marriage with academic degrees, and he completed his studies and professional path even before marriage (without help or sacrifice from the plaintiff). He emphasizes that the plaintiff voluntarily chose not to work or exhaust her earning capacity for personal convenience, not due to physical or mental hardship caused by it, and therefore no unequal compensation or distribution of earning capacity should be awarded in her favor.
- After considering the parties' arguments, my conclusion is that the plaintiff has not proven that this is an exceptional case justifying an unequal division of the parties' assets in resource equalization.
- The claims raised by the plaintiff regarding the defendant's violence should not be taken lightly. These claims are indeed intertwined with the many proceedings between the parties. Recordings were played before the court during the hearing, showing that the defendant was shouting and cursing, and the plaintiff and her father testified about incidents of various types of violence. However, as a rule, violence itself does not constitute a reason for unequal division on grounds of punishment or automatic compensation. The use is exceptional, limited, and proportionate, and usually a connection is required between the violence and economic harm or violation of the distinct personal rights of the injured spouse, a connection that has not been proven.
- In CA 7272/10 [Nevo], to which the plaintiff referred, a general unequal division of all the couple's assets was not established. A specific exception was established: the attempted murder of the spouse justified the removal of pension rights dependent on her from the resource balancing under Section 8, while the rest of the property remained divided equally. The ruling emphasizes that this is an exception to extreme cases, and not at all where the very act of violence or the very fault in the dissolution of the marriage leads to an unequal division.
- In the High Court of Justice case 6037/18 Plonit v. Tel Aviv-Jaffa Regional Rabbinical Court [Nevo] (18.2.2019), the approach of Honorable Judge Hendel was applied in CA 7272/10 [Nevo], emphasizing that violence does not by itself justify denial of property rights, but only when there is a connection between the violence and the economic situation of the injured spouse.
- The plaintiff claimed the connection as stated, stating that the defendant's violent behavior and the severe pressure she was under caused an outbreak of "acute arthritis" in her body, as detailed above.
- However, these claims of the plaintiff were not proven-she did not attach medical documents to prove the arthritis and did not prove the causal link between her illness and the defendant's violence. She also did not prove harm to her earning capacity due to the defendant. As mentioned above, the parties' marriages were brief; both were academics even before their marriage, married at age 27, and separated in their mid-thirties, so these are young people whose professional peak is still ahead of them. Moreover, a "huge" income gap between the parties during the marriage was not proven, as the plaintiff claims.
- The conclusion is that claims of violence, although they cannot be dismissed, are insufficient. Since the connection between the violence and the plaintiff's alleged financial situation was not proven, the violence itself does not justify denying the defendant's property rights.
- The claim for an unequal distribution within the framework of resource equalization of social rights is therefore rejected.
The debt to the caregiver Dr. K.
- The plaintiff claims that the debt to therapist Dr. , which arose from psychological treatments using the EMDR method, is a clear personal debt of the defendant intended to address his issues of violence, anger, and post-trauma. In her view, this debt was created for a clear personal need that does not serve the welfare of the family unit, and therefore should not be included in the resource balancing. She adds that she herself met with the caregiver "two or three times, no more, " while the defendant was with her "dozens, if not more than a hundred" times.
- The plaintiff further claims that even before the defendant began the expensive treatment, his father committed to the parties that he would bear the astronomical costs of the treatment. She clarifies that her involvement in correspondence with the caregiver and her secretary Hannah was done solely to "soften her and talk to her" after the defendant and his father got into financial trouble with her.
- On the other hand, the defendant claims that this is a joint debt accumulated during the marriage for the purpose of "saving the family unit, " and that the plaintiff was the initiator, the "driving force, " and the driving force behind the treatment. He emphasizes that the plaintiff sent the therapist an email dated the 4th. 2019, in which she explicitly wrote: "We decided to go for it... Our married life depends on it." According to him, the plaintiff even gave him an ultimatum that if he did not continue treatment, they would divorce, thereby forcing him to continue with treatment he had accumulated a "crazy" debt.
- The defendant refers to a message sent by the plaintiff on the 29th. 2022, documenting her admission of the joint debt, where she wrote: "As of today, we are left with a debt of more than a quarter of a million, about 258,000." He clarifies that in the past two years he has had to take on the moral responsibility and pay a temporary arrangement caregiver of 1,500 ₪ per month from his own pocket. Furthermore, the defendant denies the claim that his father undertook to bear the debt and notes that the plaintiff herself admitted in her testimony that the father never committed to this to her.
- To support his claims, the defendant presented the appendix of the plaintiff's email correspondence with Dr. and her assistant Hannah (where it was noted that the debt amounted to 266,201 ILS as of 30.12.2022), detailing the payment arrangements set by the plaintiff. Additionally, a extract from the social worker's report dated 26 was presented. 9. 2023, in which the therapist confirmed that "the treatment was initially based on a list of R.'s traumas, which A.". Additionally, an amortization schedule was attached showing a debt balance of 238,200 ILS, as well as receipts for ongoing payments made by the defendant (such as a transfer of 28,000 ILS from day 1). 1. 2023 and monthly receipts of 1,500 ₪).
- The defendant points to the plaintiff's bad faith, who concealed from the court the fact that her personal treatments with the caregiver M.H. were funded during the marriage from the joint account. Additionally, the defendant explained at the hearing the recordings presented by the plaintiff as a "Pandora's box, " clarifying that he meant that if he refused to pay the caregiver, she would sue him, and he would have to make false allegations of violence in court just to prove that the treatment did not work and to disavow the debt.
- As mentioned above, the plaintiff stayed in a shelter for women victims of violence for a long period. This fact alone constitutes primary evidence of the defendant's violence. Additionally, in the case concerning the parties' son (claims after the settlement of litigation 37175-07-23 [Nevo]), the plaintiff submitted correspondences between her and the defendant, which allegedly included a confession by the defendant regarding his violent behavior. For example, in the correspondence dated 7.2.2021, the following exchanges appear:
Plaintiff: Who will guarantee me that you won't slap me again, shake me, hit objects?