Caselaw

Claims after the settlement of litigation (Jerusalem) 47839-07-23 A.B. v. R.B. - part 8

October 8, 2026
Print

The defendant: "It was not intended for you.  "

Prosecutor: It doesn't matter, you really don't understand.

Defendant: I have handled all of the above.

Prosecutor: When you're out of control, you do things you're shocked by.

Defendant: I treated all the physical violent behaviors.

...

Prosecutor: You are the only one who does not see the picture as it is, who does not understand the severity of your behavior.

Defendant: I see, but that's why I'm going for treatment.

  1. And on 5.8.2022, the following exchange appears:

Prosecutor: I am very exhausted.

Defendant: I understand.

Plaintiff: I am physically exhausted insanely and you exhausted me mentally insanely, as well as N.

Defendant: I understand.

The plaintiff: He couldn't stop crying that Dad treated him as if he was a floor and that Dad couldn't get over it and was uncomfortable.

Defendant: Yes, I know.  Ugh.  It saddens me a lot.  I'm tired of falling like this.

The plaintiff: He said: Dad says not to shout and he yells at me, Dad says not to push and he pushed me, and Dad said not to hurt and he hurts me.  Only 5 minutes ago did he calm down.  He cried the second we entered the elevator.

Defendant: It's terrible, really, simply terrible.

  1. In a recording of a conversation between the parties submitted by the plaintiff, the defendant allegedly admitted to his violent behavior:

Defendant: And this [meaning treatment with Dr.  K., M.B.] It didn't work.  Now I don't intend to go to court and say: "Here I pushed, I behaved violently, I was taken off the balcony, " I don't remember, various things, "I took it out on the balcony, I shouted, shook..." I pushed my son.  "I don't intend to do it to myself because I will open a Pandora's box on myself that I don't want to take out.  But what, these things happened, and that means it didn't work.  " [emphasis mine, M.B.].

  1. From the above, it should be inferred that the treatment with Dr. was done due to the defendant's violence and in an attempt to bring about its cessation.
  2. Under these circumstances, the defendant's position that the parties should bear equal shares of the debt to the caregiver cannot be accepted, since the plaintiff was a victim of his violence and she should not be required to pay the defendant equally for the cost of the violence mitigation treatment. In addition, the very fact that the defendant went to Dr.   for treatment constitutes his recognition of the problem he has and the need to solve it in order to save the parties' married life.
  3. On the other hand, considering her involvement in the treatment, her consent to its cost, and her regard of the debt as joint, the plaintiff must bear a certain part of the debt, which is ultimately a debt subject to balancing according to the provisions of the Property Relations Law between spouses, 1973.
  4. I cannot accept the plaintiff's claim that the defendant's father committed to pay for the treatment with Dr. .  The plaintiff did not request to summon the father (who is not a party in the proceedings) to clarify this matter, and therefore her claim was not proven.
  5. Under these circumstances, and considering the above reasons, my conclusion is that both parties must bear the debt but not in equal shares. In balancing the parties' arguments, it is found that the debt to Dr.   should be divided between the parties so that the defendant bears 80% of it and the plaintiff 20%.

The result

  1. The claim for specific sharing of the defendant's apartment in xxx is dismissed.
  2. The claim for an unequal division of the resource equalization outcomes is denied. The equalization of the parties' social rights for the partnership period will be carried out in accordance with the provisions of Section 5(a) of the Property Relations Between Spouses Law, 1973, so that each party is entitled to half the value of all assets.  The partnership period - from the date of the parties' marriage on 00.00.2016 until the date of separation, 10.2.2023.
  3. The demand to impose the full debt on the defendant to the caregiver Dr. is rejected, but the defendant's position for an equal division of the debt is also rejected, and it will be divided so that the defendant bears 80% of it and the plaintiff 20%.
  4. Under the circumstances, and considering that the claim was partially accepted, each party will bear its own costs.

Given today, 27 Tishrei 5787, October 8,2026, in the absence of the parties.

Previous part1...78
9Next part
Skip to content