ביום 5.9.2000, נכנסה גב' הוניגמן לחניון הסמוך לבית החולים בחיפה. משראתה כי מקומות החנייה תפוסים, הציע לה הסדרן כי תעמיד רכבה בחנייה כפולה, תשאיר בידו את מפתחות הרכב וכשיתפנה מקום חניה, יעביר הסדרן את רכבה למקום מסודר, וכך עשתה. כאשר הרכב נגנב (יחד עם המפתחות), הגישה חברת הביטוח תביעה כנגד הסדרן, כנגד בעלת החניון וכנגד מנהלת החברה המנהלת את החניון. בית המשפט העליון קבע כי על המנהלת מוטלת אחריות נזיקית בשל חובת הזהירות אשר מוטלת עליה בעיקר בשל העובדה כי המנהלת, היא שיזמה את עניין החניות הכפולות אשר יצר פרצות אשר לא טופלו על ידה כראוי. בעלת החניון חויבה גם היא בפיצויי התובעת הואיל ושמרה לעצמה את זכויות הפיקוח על פעולות החניון, אישור פעולות החברה המנהלת את החניון וקביעת הנחיות ונהלים בניהול החניון. בית המשפט קבע כי בעלת החניון כשלה ולא וידאה כי תפעולו וניהולו של החניון נעשה כראוי ועל פי הסטנדרטים הנדרשים.
Published in Afik News 040, 07.01.2010
Related articles
A company shareholders register is ostensibly evidence of its correctness but extra caution is required in familial relationships
Business, Corporate and Joint Ventures
Trusts
Dispute Resolution
A father and son purchased a factory through a company that was established and all of its shares were recorded in the son’s name. After a dispute arose between the parties, the father sought to amend the registration of shares to reflect his ownership of half of the company, contending that he was involved int […]
An agreement between sophisticated parties will not be interpreted contrary to its wording even if this leads to a commercially unreasonable result
Business, Corporate and Joint Ventures
Mergers and Acquisitions
Dispute Resolution
After selling their company, the sellers demanded additional consideration from the purchaser under the sale agreement, on the basis that the sales targets had been met. However, the agreement clarified that the additional consideration would apply only to sales of the company’s original products, whereas in practice the sales were of new products not included […]
Lack of agreement on all the terms of a contract, including the consideration, will not necessarily prevent its perfection
Commercial, Banking and Financial
Dispute Resolution
A subcontractor and the main contractor negotiated and exchanged drafts of an agreement regarding the termination of their engagement and the completion of the subcontractor’s obligations by the main contractor before the completion of the works that were the subject of the current agreement between them. However, while the formula for calculating the consideration for […]
The threshold conditions for recognizing the existence of a “common-law spouse” relationship are family life and a shared household
Notarial Prenups
Wills and Estates
Intergenerational Law (Trusts, Estates, Lasting Powers of Attorney, Parenting)
A woman sought to be recognized as a common-law spouse of a deceased on the grounds that she and him had lived together as husband and wife for several years until his demise, and thus be recognized as his heir. The Court refused to acknowledge the woman as a common-law spouse. Common-law spouses are spouses […]