During arbitration proceedings between former clients (the Gertner family) and Adv. Yaakov Weinroth. Weinroth passed away and his heirs joined the proceedings as substitutes to continue managing it. The arbitrator held that the estate and the heirs are "jointly and severally" liable for USD 37.5 million, thereby imposing personal liability on the heirs and their private assets.
The Supreme Court held that the heirs are not personally liability for the debts of the estate, beyond their part in the estate. Under the Israeli Arbitration Law, an arbitration agreement and the arbitrator's authority pursuant thereto apply also to the substitutes of the parties to the agreement. Under the Israeli Succession Law, any debt left by the deceased becomes a debt of the estate, and until the distribution of the estate, the heirs are liable for debts solely from the estate's assets. After the distribution of the estate, imposing personal liability on the heirs is limited to the value of what they received from the estate, or up to the value of the entire estate if distributed without summoning creditors while the heir had knowledge of the debt at the time of distribution. In the present case, although the heirs are responsible for satisfying the arbitral award from the estate's assets, this does not mean that personal liability can be imposed on them to bear the debt from their private assets. The heirs' willingness to step into the deceased's shoes for the purpose of conducting the arbitration does not indicate implied consent to extend the arbitrator's authority to the question of their personal liability. Therefore, in the absence of express or implied consent from the heirs, the arbitrator lacked authority to adjudicate their personal liability and if the creditors wish to impose personal liability on the heirs and pursue their private assets, they must file a separate claim with a competent Court.