Caselaw

Class Action (Tel Aviv) 11278-10-19 Yehoshua Klein v. Oil Refineries Ltd. - part 126

January 13, 2026
Print

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          Even if the degree of pollution is from the power station, you have not checked the electricity generation?

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        What do you mean I didn't check?

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          You don't know what part of the pollution comes from electricity generation

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        True, but I know that electricity generation also causes morbidity and cancer.  I mean, I didn't have to prove these things, I didn't have to prove again that air pollution causes cancer, lung disease, and no vascular disease.  This does not need to be proven. 

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          No need to prove.

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        This has been proven in the medical literature in tens and hundreds and thousands of articles

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          There is no need to prove that transportation and power generation cause L. 

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        Nor is air pollution from industry.  There is no need to prove that this is a cause because it has actually already been said, the World Health Organization through its bodies says the substances are P 2.5 which is one of the indicators of air pollution, it is a substance that is defined as carcinogenic, so I don't have to prove it now again in the State of Israel

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          You are aware that smoke from ships, there is emission of pollutants from ships in the port?

The witness, Prof. A.  Grotto:        This, too, there are many sources of pollution that people are exposed to.  Our goal, as a public health advocate, is to reduce as much as possible the sources that can be reduced, the PM2.5 that I talked about earlier cannot always be reduced.  Some of it comes from a struggle from Africa and we have nothing to do, but the part that we can deal with is our job to deal with

Adv. Dr. Tal Rotman:          I mean, you are actually, if I understand you correctly, you are saying that there are a lot of sources of pollution.  There's transportation, there's a port, there's electricity generation, and there's what you said, desert dust.  Right? And there is also industry and everyone together pollutes and I try to reduce where I can

Previous part1...125126
127...200Next part