Caselaw

Civil Case (Center) 4585-02-19 Ephraim Naveh v. Hadas Steif - part 19

October 5, 2026
Print

And yes: "I feel the weight that as far as I'm concerned, this is the Israeli Watergate affair, I understand that such material cannot remain in the dark.  I'm a journalist who exposes corruption and conducts investigations...  I ask Yuli to stop and put everything on my USB drive, and I have to inform Shimon Elkabetz, the commander of the Galatz station, at this time.  I call Shimon and tell him that I have a story that is bigger than me, we have to deal with it...  We must meet and today" (Par.  p.  164, paras.  3-8).

I therefore determine that Shteif was aware of the improper manner in which the information was extracted from Naveh's mobile phones, i.e., technological hacking and arranging the contents in folders.  Her conduct in the framework of the meeting, as emerged from Shteif's testimony, testifies to the fact that she positively approved the improper move, and even instructed Yuli as to how to sort the information extracted from the mobile phones, in order to serve The The investigative journalism in Naveh's case. 

  1. After the meeting at Yuli's home, Shteif went straight to a meeting with Shimon Elkabetz, the commander of Army Radio and the station's editor-in-chief at the time. The two arranged to meet at a café in Ashdod, near his place of residence.  In his testimony before me, Elkabetz explained that he had received a "very excited and very excited" phone call from Steif, who explained to him that they had to meet urgently because "I have a big story" (par.  p.  396, paras.  6-8).
  2. On her way to a meeting with Elkabetz, Shteif contacted Hani by phone in order to obtain her consent to publish the materials produced from the devices. This is what emerged from her testimony:

"When I leave Yuli, Shimon used to live in Ashdod, he tells me we'll meet in a café, it was near his house, I go out to him and make a very general and preliminary stenogram of what's in the materials and write down a few things.  I call Chani because Chani's phones, I'm committed to Chani and Chani asked Yuli if he can take care of them, there's nothing I can do, I understand that I can't do anything with the materials before she knows about it.  Karma is a Beach, Chani tells me I'm on my way to Ashkelon I have family there I'm on my way to console mourners, I told her to stop at the Silver compound I want to talk to you and so it was.  I'm on my way from Ashkelon to Ashdod, the two of us are standing outside the car and I tell her what I'm going to tell Shimon and I ask her if she agrees that we publish things and she tells me clearly, and as soon as possible.  I told her I wanted you to know that your phones are yours and I don't want to do something you don't agree to.  She told me the opposite - that it should be published and as soon as possible and then we say goodbye and I continue to Ashdod."

Previous part1...1819
20...67Next part
Skip to content