- Quantitative criteria - Another argument of the appellant, as stated, concerns the reasonableness and weight of the quantitative criteria for the bidder's quality score. On this level, it was argued, inter alia, that a clear advantage was given to "large" firms over other bidders.
This argument, as the trial court held, is also unfounded. First, there is no room to accept the argument that the quantitative criteria are not relevant to the evaluation of the bidders in the tender. As the Respondent clarified, the criterion regarding the size of the bidder indicates, to a certain extent, his ability to handle the cases that will be transferred to him; and the criterion regarding the quantity of proceedings indicates the bidder's experience in the relevant field. Second, out of the total score for quality indices, the quantitative criteria constitute a relatively small part (15 points out of 65). In particular, with regard to the size of the bidder, the quantitative criterion can give the bidder, at most, an advantage of only 4 points (a point for any additional lawyer beyond the three that are required as a prerequisite, up to a maximum score of 4 points). Therefore, there is no basis for the claim that the weight given to the quantitative criteria is unreasonable, or that they give an unfair advantage to the bidders "Adults" (To a large extent, the opposite is true - The provisions of the tender do not confer any advantage on a firm with more than 7 lawyers).
In this context, too, it is not superfluous to mention the rule according to which judicial intervention In Contents The tender will be in exceptional cases only, and only where there is a material deviation from the basic principles of the tenders laws (see: AAA 6466/19 Ministry of Defense v. Nursing Companies Association, paragraph 14 and the references therein [Posted inNevo] (11.10.2020) (hereinafter: The Issue of Nursing Companies); 77"m 5655/20 Children and Youth Village "Love" - Association for the Advancement of Children, Youth and Youth at Risk v. State of Israel, paragraph 28 [Posted inNevo] (February 9,2021)). This is not the case at hand.
- The uniqueness of the legal profession - and hence the appellant's last argument in principle, with regard to the alleged contradiction between the provisions of the tender and the laws of ethics. In the trial court, this argument was based both on the provisions of the law regarding the uniqueness of the profession, and on the duty to distinguish between the payment of legal fees and reimbursement of expenses. The District Court rejected both arguments. As stated above, in the hearing before us, the respondent agreed to cancel clause 110 and to add a clarifying clause to the tender regarding the payment of reimbursement of expenses. Thus, the argument on this level was resolved.
Therefore, the argument remains that the provisions of the tender, which allow the transfer of files to the management company, which is not a law firm, violates the Article 20 30The Bar Association Law which indicates the uniqueness of the profession.