The law of this argument is rejection. The tender does not authorize the management company, at no stage, to carry out actions unique to the legal profession; and so did the trial court (paragraph 31 of the judgment). This conclusion is also consistent with the presumption of administrative integrity and its application in the tenders laws (see, Mini-Many: The Matter Nursing Companies, paragraph 14). As the Respondent clarified, sometimes the required handling of cases is negligible and non-legal, such as sending letters to the local authorities; and for this purpose there is no impediment to the handling being transferred to the management company. The respondent is presumed that the cases that will be transferred to the management company will not require taking actions that are unique to the legal profession.
- Expenses awarded by the District Court - The appellant also appealed the judgment of the first instance against the sum of expenses awarded to him in the sum of ILS 40,000. Given the result regarding the dismissal of the appeal, and in view of the rule that only in rare cases will the appellate court intervene in an award of costs by the trial court (see, among many: Civil Appeal 276/09 Taba v. Israel Lands Administration, para. 23 and the references there [published in Nevo] (January 2,2011)), I find this argument to be rejected.
- On the basis of all of the above, I found that both the appellant's claims of infringement of his procedural rights should be rejected; and his arguments against the tender, on the merits of the matter (except for the argument that was resolved in the hearing before us, with the consent of the respondent).
As to the question of dismissing the petition in limine, due to the date of its filing, I will address this immediately.
Prevention - The Question Under Discussion
- An authority has published a tender. Prior to the deadline for submitting the proposals, Reuven, who intends to participate in the tender, raises claims before the tenders committee about defects that he claims were in the tender. The tenders committee rejects Reuven's claims. Reuven submits a proposal within the framework of the tender, without protest. After the deadline for submitting bids has passed, but before the identity of the winner of the tender is published, Reuven submits a petition against the terms of the tender, based on the same arguments he raised earlier and were rejected. Should Reuven's petition be rejected due to impediment or delay?
This is the question before us.
- The aforementioned question can be examined in two legal instruments, which have considerable similarities between them, especially in the context of the specific issue in tenders law that we are dealing with:
הראשון - Delay Laws. In this regard, the case law is relevant according to which in tenders, even a short period of time can constitute a delay that justifies the rejection of the petition (see, for example: Bar"m 995/02 Jaljuli Planning and Execution G.L. 1996 Ltd."M v. Irit al-Tira [Posted inNevo] (19.2.2002); Bar"m 5677/02 Mediterranean Car Agency Ltd."M v. State of Israel [Posted inNevo] (July 5,2002)). It was further held that even when there are circumstances of delay, the petition may not be dismissed where it indicates Harm to the Rule of Law (77"m 2273/03 Blue Island General Partnership v. Society for the Protection of Nature in Israel, paragraphs 96-99 [Posted inNevo] (7.12.2006)).