Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 20

December 10, 2023
Print

From the above passage we return to the opposite conclusion, according to which the critical date is actually the date on which the bidder became aware that he did not win the tender.

We should not be surprised by the lack of clarity that we discussed above: Galilee Tours The facts were that the Petitioner submitted her petition after she learned that she had not won the tender.  Therefore, the distinction between the date of submission of the bids and the date of publication of the identity of the winner of the tender, with regard to the critical date for the creation of the impediments - is the discernment at the heart of the question we seek to solve - was irrelevant.

  1. It is important to note that the impediments mentioned in the Galilee Trips rule are not absolute. As was also determined in the quotation quoted above from the judgment in the Engelsman case, where it was argued in the petition that the tender was tainted by illegality, then, as a rule, the argument of inhibition will be withdrawn in the face of the public interest in maintaining proper and proper public conduct, which is promoted by clarifying the petition's arguments on their merits (see, in addition to the Engelsman case, also the High Court of Justice 5377/90 Levy v.  Ashdod Municipality [published in Nevo] (January 16,1991) (hereinafter: the Levy case); AAA 5498/09 New Eli at the Port Ltd.    Dead Sea Works Treasury, paragraphs 8-9 [published in Nevo] (October 11,2011); AAA 2398/12 A.M.T.  Measurement Channels and Infrastructures Ltd.  v.  Shoham Economic Company Ltd., para.  14 [published in Nevo] (April 22,2012) (hereinafter: A.M.T.); and another position, according to which impediment may sometimes override illegality: Civil Appeals Authority 5979/12 Olitsky Earthworks Roads and Development Ltd.  v.  Effa Landfills Ltd., para.  12 [published in Nevo] (August 21,2012) (hereinafter: the Olitzky case); Dafna Barak-Erez Administrative Law - Economic Administrative Law, Vol.  3, No. 192 (2013) (hereinafter: Barak-Erez, Economic Administrative Law)).
  2. About 40 years have passed since the Galilee Tours rule was issued . A large number of judgments have been given on the issue of impediments in the context of filing a petition in tender law.  However, and as we will see below, it is doubtful whether it is possible to find a clear answer to the question that was posed in the judgments that were rendered.

A significant portion of the rulings are quoted, or cited by way of "Paraphrase", the beginning of the matters that were determined in the matter Galilee Tours - "The rule is that a person cannot participate in a tender on the one hand and raise claims against him on the other hand, once it turns out that he did not win it" (See, for example, the matter Levy; Civil Appeal 4683/97 Knowledge Computers & Software Ltd."M v.  State of Israel, פ"D.  51(5) 643,646 (1997); 77"m 7357/03 Ports Authority v.  Junction Engineers Planning, Coordination and Project Management Ltd."From, פ"49(2) 145,166 (2004); 77"m 8610/03 Amnon Mesilot Ma'ale Shosh Sela Center v.  Majar Local Council, פ"D.  58(6) 755,763 (2004); 77"m 1873/12 Assum Building Contracting Company Ltd."M v.  University בן גוריון In the Negev, paragraph 6 of the judge's judgment v.  Hendel [Posted inNevo] (6.8.2012); 77"m 1981/02 Caesar - Engineering & Development Ltd."M v.  State of Israel (24.3.2002); Bar"m 2190/20 G&B Packing Co.  N.  Serra International, Inc., paragraph 31 [Posted inNevo] (25.10.2020); 77"m 4529/15 ORT Israel v.  Daliyat al-Carmel Local Council, paragraph 10 [Posted inNevo] (24.8.2015)).

Previous part1...1920
21...32Next part
Skip to content