Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 21

December 10, 2023
Print

However, what the following rulings have in common is"30 is similar to the rule of Galilee Tours itself, with regard to the formulation of precludes from filing a petition against the terms of the tender, the distinction between the date of submission of the bids and the date of publication of the identity of the winning bidder.  Therefore, all of the above references cannot be considered as providing an answer to the question presented above.

  1. There is also a case law that referred to the Galilee Tours Rule as determining the date of submission of bids as the relevant date for creating the impediments to attack the terms of the tender (see: BRAM 6745/10 Tour Travelers Ltd.   Ashdod Port Company Ltd., paragraph 8 [published in Nevo] (September 21,2010) (hereinafter: the Tor Travelers case); The A.M.T.  Case, paragraph 14).
  2. Other rulings, which addressed the "duplication" that appeared in the Galilee Trips rule, in the sense that on the one hand, they recalled the rule that a participant could not petition against the tender after learning that he had lost, and on the other hand, they also included statements that relate specifically to the date of submission of the bids as the relevant date for formulating the impediments.

Thus, for example, in Decision BBar"m 6571/05 Ehud Meir Pumping Ltd."M v.  Tel Aviv Municipality [Posted inNevo] (July 25,2005), it was held that: "This court has already ruled many times that a bidder, who believes that there was a defect in the tender but does not argue against it but only After it became known that he did not merit, will be prevented from hearing this claim"; In the same breath, the rule was mentioned: "A person wishing to attack a tender due to a defect in its terms is required to do so as soon as possible and before he submits his proposal" (Emphasis added - 10:20; See also: High Court of Justice 430/89 Maor Signage & Outdoor Advertising Ltd."M v.  Kfar Saba Municipality, פ"D 33(3) 269,270 (August 13,1989); 77"m 2914/09 Magen David Adom Society in Israel v.  State of Israel, paragraph 13 of the judge's judgment Y.  Amit [Posted inNevo] (24.11.2009)).

Previous part1...2021
22...32Next part
Skip to content