The reason for mentioning, in the same breath, legal statements between which there is a difference, stems from the same reason that I discussed above in my reference to the judgment in the case Galilee Tours - The circumstances of the matter discussed in that judgment did not necessitate the distinction, with regard to impediments, between the filing of the petition after the submission of the bids and before the publication of the tender results and the filing of the petition after the publication of the tender results.
It should be noted that there is no dispute that where the petition was submitted before the deadline for submitting bids in the tender has passed, - There was no impediment to the filing of the petition, even if the petitioner had already submitted his proposal (see in this regard: AAA 6629/21 Atlantis Agricultural Training Centers Inc."M. v. Ministry of Foreign Affairs - Mesh Division"II, paragraph 7 [Posted inNevo] (March 14,2022) (hereinafter: The Atlantis Interest)).
- Judgments of this court, which dealt with the circumstances in which the petition was filed after the submission of the bids but prior to the publication of the identity of the winner of the tender, are, as far as I know, few:
In the matter AAA 4622/09 Jerusalem Radio Broadcasting (2007) Ltd."M v. Second Authority for Television and Radio [Posted inNevo] (August 23,2009), the Appellant filed a petition against the tender in the intermediate stage between the closing of the bid box and the announcement of the winner. The Appellant withdrew this petition, and after the decision was made on the winner of the tender - filed her petition again. This court rejected the Petitioner's arguments on their merits, but added, with regard to the argument of precludions, the following:
"As is well known, a participant in a tender is not entitled to wait for the announcement of the winner of the tender and then raise arguments relating to the integrity of the tender proceedings, when the facts underlying them were known to him in real time [and here the court refers to the Galilee Tours rule - Y. 20]. However, it should be remembered that in our case, the appellant turned to the judicial courts before the tender proceedings were completed. This petition was indeed deleted, but all of the appellant's arguments were reserved for her. In any event, an examination of the appellant's arguments on their merits, reveals that in the circumstances of the case there is no reason to disqualify the tender proceedings" (ibid., paragraph 6).