Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 23

December 10, 2023
Print

In the above statement we can find some support for the conclusion that there is no room for an outright rejection of the petition of the "Reuven" (Paragraph 48 above) for reasons of impediments.  This is because there is no reason to dismiss the Appellant's petition in the matter Jerusalem Broadcasting due to impediments, even though it submitted its bid to the tender after it withdrew its petition that was submitted prior to the deadline for submitting bids, and this could have been seen as the appellant's agreement to the terms of the tender.  At the same time, it is clear that the above statement cannot be found to constitute a precedent in this matter (both because it lacks any positive determination, and because it is an explicit and clear incidental statement, and because of the lack of reasoning).

Certain support, for the same conclusion, can also be found in the judgment in77"m 6217/02 Shlomit - Association for the Employment of Volunteers in the National Service v.  Ministry of Education, Culture and Sport [Posted inNevo] (July 31,2002).  In this case, an appeal was accepted, with the consent of the parties, against a judgment of the District Court that determined that a participant in a tender whose reservation was not received was prevented from filing a petition, since she submitted her bid for the tender and did not petition against its terms before the deadline for submitting bids had passed.Time"m 1241/02 Shlomit - Association for the Employment of Volunteers in the National Service v.  Ministry of Education, Culture and Sport [Posted inNevo] (June 17,2002)).  This Court returned the hearing to the Court for Administrative Affairs to hear the petition on the merits of the matter, "without the fact that the appellant did not violate the threshold requirement as a reason for rejecting the petition in limine".  It should be recalled that this is a judgment given by consent and without any reasoning.

 

  1. On the other hand, support for the opposite position can be found in AAA 3212/12 Yirmiyahu Levandiger - Etgar Private and Security Investigations v. State of Israel [published in Nevo] (September 24,2012) (hereinafter: the Levandiger case).  In this case, the appellant accepted the court's recommendation to withdraw his appeal, a recommendation that was given, as stipulated in the judgment: "mainly because [the appellant] participated in the tender even though he raised objections to his lawyers, instead of taking appropriate steps."

However, a review of the judgment of the District Court, the subject of the appeal in the matter of Levandiger, shows that the petition in that case was filed after the identity of the winner of the tender was published, so that even the determination quoted above does not clearly answer the question that we have raised.

Previous part1...2223
24...32Next part
Skip to content