- We will also mention once again the judgment in the Engelsman case, and note that the judgment revolved around the predecessor of the tender in question, which was published in 2010. In this case, the Petitioner raised its arguments, before the tenders committee, after the submission of the bids and prior to the declaration of the winner of the tender, but applied to the court only after the tender winner was declared. This court stood on the principles of delay and precluions, and further determined the following:
"The petitions are also tainted by impediments. Engelsman did indeed contact the tenders committee and the Attorney General prior to the publication of the tenders committee's decision regarding the winners, and therefore the Galilee tours rule is not as it is. However, the proximity of the time between the date of raising the claim and the date of publication of the tenders committee's decision, together with the lack of explanation for the timing of its raising, justify applying this rule to Engelsman's case as well. "
The statement that "The Galilee Tours Rule is not as it is" and the additional reasoning required by the court to determine that there are impediments may hint at some support for the determination that the petition of the "Reuven", in the question that we have raised, should not be dismissed out of hand for reasons of impediments. However, even in this judgment there is no determination on the matter at hand, and yes, as we have seen above, to"Language" of the ruling Galilee ToursThere is, in this context, more than one aspect.
- Our journey through the rulings of this court did not, I believe, lead to finding an answer to the fundamental question that we posed. Indeed, in the judgment in AAA 9289/20 Lite TLVNT. v. Detachment of Municipal Transportation Lines Estates for Mass Transportation Ltd. [published in Nevo] (May 20,2021), Justice A. Grosskopf noted the lack of clarity in the case law regarding the date of the formulation of the preclusions:
"Insofar as the matter relates to the validity of the committee' s authority, it is possible that arguments on this level could have been rejected already on the ground that the appellant did not validate the provision of clause 3.13 of the tender documents prior to the date of submission of the bids in the tender. However, there is also a case law which indicates that the determining date in this matter is the date of publication of the results of the tender, and not the date of submission of the proposals" (references omitted - Y. 20; ibid., paragraph 17).
- The appellant referred to the book of the scholar Dekel, Tenders (Volume Two), pp. 274-275, as support for his arguments on the issue at hand.
Indeed, the opinion expressed there is that if the participant in the tender presented his reservations to the tender arranger before the deadline for submitting the proposals, then if his reservations were rejected and he subsequently submitted a proposal, waited until it became clear that his bid did not win and filed a petition only afterwards, there is no reason to reject his petition for reasons of impediments.