Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 25

December 10, 2023
Print

The learned author is aware of the reasons in the public interest that are against his opinion, but in his view, reasons should be preferred over them, the summary of which is as follows: It is difficult to expect a bidder to turn to the courts before the tender is decided, due to the fear that this will harm his chances of success; A legal confrontation has costs and it is difficult to demand that a bidder invest it without knowing that if his legal path succeeds, he will win the tender; For all of these reasons, the bidder, in the circumstances described above, should not be regarded as having waived his claims by not approaching the court; There is no justification in a situation in which the bidder warns and the committee does not listen to him, to block the bidder's way to court.

It should be noted that the above position is even far-reaching from what is necessary for our case, since it also relates to a person who submitted his petition after the results of the tender were published (provided that he presented his arguments, prior to the submission of the proposal, before the tender arranger).

I do not agree with the aforementioned opinion, and this is because it contradicts, in my opinion, the case law (and see the quote quoted above is interesting Levandiger See also the matter of Tours Travelers), and because it absolutely prefers the interests of the bidder who is considering whether to approach the court at one time or another, over the interest of reliance of the other parties involved in the tender and the interest of the public as a whole.  In my opinion, there is no place for this.  Moreover, with regard to the interests of the bidder who is considering whether to file a petition on time, the learned author wishes to recognize and give weight (and even decisive weight) to considerations that in my opinion it is highly doubtful whether for reasons in proper legal policy there is room to recognize them at all (starting with the bidder's alleged fear of raising the wrath of the tenders committee lest it repay him when it determines the identity of the winner, and ending with the bidder's willingness to invest the required money for the purpose of financing legal proceedings only if winning the tender is guaranteed following their success).

  1. Another position is expressed by the scholar Herzig, In his book Tender Law - Remedies in Tender Law (2014).  This source states that: "Most of the rulings relate to impediments to attacking the terms of a tender after the petitioner has lost it, but for the reason for the preclude - Consent learned from participation in a tender - It follows that the impediments apply from the time the petitioner submitted his bid for the tender, and part of the case law insists on this" (Name, p.  176).  With regard to the case of the bidder who warned even before the submission of the bids in the tender, but when it was rejected, submitted a bid and approached the court only afterwards, the opinion is expressed that in these cases the subjective aspect, centered on the petitioner's conduct, does not justify rejection in limine due to impediments, and therefore the objective aspect, which focuses on the degree of reliance, power and practice, of the tender arranger, the bidders, and the potential bidders must be considered, in any case (See: Name, p.  184).

As clarified below, my position is that in such circumstances there is also a difficulty in the subjective context.

  1. Since I have not been able to locate a ruling by the respondent on the question that we have set, I will seek to find the answer to the reasons underlying the application of the precludions in the context at hand. This was already expressed in the reasoning for the Galilee Trips rule, as well as in the case law that follows.  In this context, I will adopt, for the sake of convenience, the division between the subjective aspect relating to the participant in the tender who submitted the petition (on the date he filed it), and the objective aspect that focuses on the legitimate interests of all the participants in the tender and the public as a whole.

In the subjective aspect - The focus, in my opinion, is on the petitioner's good faith, on the representation he presented in the manner in which he acted and on the possibility of acquiring an unfair advantage and manipulation.

Previous part1...2425
26...32Next part
Skip to content