From the objective point of view - The focus is on the interests of the tender arranger, the other participants in it and the potential participants therein, and their legitimate reliance on the fact that no petition was filed in the matter of the tender (until such a petition was filed). This adds another dimension: in a significant part of the cases, the significance of accepting the petition is the cancellation of the tender. This result has undesirable consequences both for the tender arranger, for the participants therein and for the public at large (an aspect that was further emphasized in the ruling Galilee ToursIn the general context, see, of many: AAA 7561/01 Finch v. Minister of Construction and Housing, פ"D 57(3) 611,621 (2003); AAA 8409/09 Hofri Hasharon Ltd."M v. A.I.L. Sela (1991) Ltd."From, paragraph 82 of the judge's judgment א' רובינשטיין [Published in Nevo] (24.5.2010)). This, in particular, where the cancellation of the tender was made After Submission of the bids and their opening, in which case there is a concern that the element of confidentiality of the new tender that will be published under the canceled tender will be violated (and see: High Court of Justice 368/76 Gozlan v. Beit Shemesh Local Council, פ"41(1) 505,515 (1977); Civil Appeal 6283/94 "Lamp" Easy Aharon Ltd."M v. State of Israel, פ"41(1) 21,26 (1997); Civil Appeal 5035/98 Moshe"In Housing Construction & Development Company Ltd."M v. Israel Lands Administration, פ"46(4) 11,27 (2002)).
Let us now move on to the examination of the petition of the "Reuven" (paragraph 48 above) and to compare it, on the one hand, to a situation in which the petition is filed before the date of submission of the bids in a tender (in which case it is clear that there is no basis for an argument of impediment (see, from the recent period: the Atlantis, paragraph 7), and on the other hand, to the situation in which the petition is filed after the identity of the winner of the tender has become known.
- From the subjective perspective - in terms of good faith and the prevention of manipulation, "Reuven" appears to be fundamentally different from someone who submitted his petition only after learning that he had not won the tender. This is because "Reuven's" behavior lacks the dimension of the sense of basic unfairness that exists with regard to someone who is willing to participate in the "rules of the game" that were determined in advance, and turns his skin only when it becomes clear that the result is not in his favor.
However, the above is only partial: often, shortly after the submission of bids in a tender, it is revealed "Reuven" information that he did not have before submitting his proposal. The same applies to the submission of bids by other bidders, the number of those bidders, and thus, sometimes, also their identity. This information can remove a significant part of the uncertainty regarding the winnership or non-win of the bidder. "Reuven" in a tender, and to bring it closer to the place where the person who submitted his petition is located only after the identity of the winner of the tender is known.