As to the implications of the remedy of cancelling the tender, it appears that they exist, to a similar extent (although not identical) - The violation of the confidentiality of the content of the proposals in the framework of the canceled tender may be less when the identity of the winner has not yet been determined), both with regard to a petition submitted after the submission of the bids and prior to the notification of the winner, and with respect to a petition submitted after the winner has been notified.
- To complete the picture, we will reiterate the question of the importance of the fact that "Reuven" argued his arguments, before the tender arranger, even before the date of submission of the bids in the tender, and that the tender arranger chose to reject them.
I consider this fact to be of non-decisive importance (except in the context that I will discuss below): the representation that the proposal is submitted without previously addressing the court in a petition is no less clear when the bidder argues his arguments, which are rejected and he nevertheless chooses to submit his proposal, than in a situation in which the bidder did not claim a defect at all until after the bids were submitted. The aforesaid circumstance - Raising the arguments before the tender publisher even before the submission of the bids - It eases the bidder's good faith to some extent (from the subjective aspect) and also promotes the public interest in encouraging such requests, if only in order to enable the tender publisher to amend what needs to be corrected, but not beyond that. In both cases, the very submission of the proposal constitutes a representation of agreement on the part of the participant to the terms of the tender - whether he raised his objections regarding the terms of the tender and these were rejected by the tenders committee (and nevertheless the participant decided that he was interested in participating in the tender as is); or whether he did not raise his objections at all before submitting his bid.
- The picture that emerges from the aforesaid is that, in view of the relevant considerations, Reuven's circumstances are not identical but are close to the circumstances of the person who submitted his petition after it became clear to him that his proposal was not successful, and far from the person who submitted his petition before the deadline for submitting proposals.
Therefore, if my opinion is heard, the answer that must be answered to the question posed above (in paragraph 48) is, as a rule, the law of the petition of the "Reuven" to be rejected out of hand for reasons of impediments. I am of the opinion that the aforesaid is also consistent with the law that is desirable in light of the existence of a public interest to encourage participants in a tender to apply to the court at the earliest possible stage and before the deadline for submitting bids (and see: Barak-Erez, Administrative Law Economical, at p. 191).