In this context, it is worth making two important remarks:
The first - As has already been emphasized above, all of the above is subject to the precedent according to which when the petitioner makes claims that indicate a violation of the rule of law, the impediments can be withdrawn in the face of the public interest in clarifying such claims.
The second - The doctrine of prevention, by its very definition (and similar to the cause of delay), is not "Binary" Rather, it leaves room for the exercise of judicial discretion in accordance with the special circumstances of the case.
- To the above, an additional aspect should be added: the circumstances of the matter at hand may raise a question relating to those cases in which the participant in a tender brings his arguments before the tenders committee even before the deadline for submitting proposals and for reasons that are not dependent on him (this is not a case, for example, a person who brought his arguments, without a good reason, at a late date), his claims are rejected on a date that is so close to the deadline for submitting proposals that he cannot be expected to submit a petition to the court before the deadline for submitting proposals.
In such a situation, it would be unfair to obligate the participant to choose between missing the deadline for submitting his bid in the framework of the tender and submitting his bid on time and creating a barrier of preventing him from bringing his claims before the court.
At the same time, it is certainly possible to expect the participant, in such circumstances, to make his intentions very clear: to inform the tender advertiser that he intends to apply to the court and that he is submitting his proposal in order not to miss the date for its submission, under protest. To the extent that the identity of the other potential bidders in the tender is known, such a notice should be sent to them as well.
In this way, the participant acts in good faith, does not attempt to obtain an improper advantage, prevents the reliance of the tender publisher on the submission of the bid by the participant (and in the event that this is possible). - also preventing the reliance of the other bidders). In addition, in this way, the tender publisher can decide that it is postponing the deadline for submitting bids for a reasonable period of time that will allow the participant to apply to the court, prior to the deadline for submitting proposals.
- In summary, my position in principle is as follows:
As a rule, a person who submitted a petition against the terms of a tender after he submitted a bid in its framework, and after the deadline for submitting bids in the framework of the tender has passed - His petition will be dismissed out of hand for reasons of impediments. This is subject to three reservations:
- When the petition raises questions of illegality or impropriety of the tender proceedings (violation of the rule of law), the court, at its discretion, can decide that the public interest in clarifying the petition outweighs the impediments.
- If the participant expressed his objections to the tender arranger, and for reasons that are not dependent on him, the answer rejecting his objections was given to him on a date that is so close to the deadline for submitting bids that he cannot be expected to submit a petition before that date - the participant can submit his proposal under protest, clarify in a written notice to the tender arranger his intention to petition the court, and if this is possible and with the knowledge of the participant - send such a notice to other potential bidders. The participant did so - there is no reason to view him as a preventer.
- Determination of preclusions, as a rule, is a matter of judicial discretion.
- And from the general to the individual:
The appellant in question received the final reply rejecting his arguments on May 17,2022, with the deadline for submitting bids on May 22,2022.