Caselaw

Causing Death by Negligent Driving (Eshed) 96-05-24 Southern District Attorney’s Office – Criminal v. Shai Yosef Haddad - part 59

October 19, 2026
Print

He testified, because the airbag computer in the specific model of the vehicle involved saves two events
And the previous ones are run over.
He testified, that the vehicle involved was removed from the lot on a forklift.

Another video for unloading the car airbag computer was done by"A tester named Yair, introduced
witness and he testified in relation to him, because it can be seen that the screws that hold the airbag computer have
Corrosion.

The witness was asked to explain the order of actions he performed before unloading information from a pillow computer
The air and he testified:
"When I receive a module of an airbag computer whose source I don't know, and what it was exposed to, I perform a test according to the procedure I studied.  I perform a visual inspection and later check how the resistance between the legs (pins) that are supposed to provide me with the information is.
Q.  Shows a video of what came out of the car.  These are the sockets, right?
A.  Yes (blue depressions) You can see the mud in the video on the road.  Destroyed vehicle
He has absolutely no suns.
Q.  You see the airbag computer after it's removed from the vehicle.  You can tell what you see
Here?
A.  Yair holds the module of the airbag computer.  You can see that the third ear is bent, there's dust there.  It shouldn't be like that.
...
A.  That the computer was removed from a vehicle that had been accidentally damaged and had a tremendous deformation.
...
Q.  We arrive at the examiner's room in Ashdod.  I make a note that with the consent of the parties in the place according to the court's decision, we will do it in Beit Dagan, but it was agreed with me that the examination will be conducted in Ashdod at an examiner's office.
In the exam room in Ashdod, you start by testing the device.  Shows you the video of testing the device.  Describe what we saw in relation to the voltage test you did? Why do you need to check voltages and why do you stop the test if the voltages are abnormal
The Court's Note:
Watch the video
A.  Before the test, I located where the pins are located from which I can extract the information.  Beyond extracting the information, which pins I need to check when the resistance is sufficiently normal.  The values between the pins, the resistance, should be normal.  I prepared equipment in advance, you can see the multimeter and I have to perform the test before I enter it with a voltage of 12 volts so as not to damage the module.  After I find that it is in order, I have the option to connect it to my equipment.  I don't want to endanger either my equipment or the module itself.  It is possible that I am doing a test and a police expert will come after me to perform the same test.  I do not want to cause damage to the findings from an action I took and not to disrupt the findings.
Q.  Showing a video.  Explain in tensions what you are looking at at each point and what you see on the side? We will go through point by point.  Describe each point what you are adding and what values were measured.
A.  I started the measurement as far as I can remember, I measure every point between the voltage of 12 volts and the 0, which is minus.  I am supposed to get a value of up to 1 ohm in this reading.  You can see that I am getting almost 12 ohms here.  When the measurement is made it is constant.  What you can see on the screen is a multimeter - with this device you measure voltages, resistances.  This is the first test I perform.  I don't pump voltage at any stage to the unit.  The resistance is actually inside the system, I am supposed to get a maximum of 1 ohm.  You can see that I am testing the resistance is 12 ohms.  As far as I am concerned, I am not concluding that it is destroyed, but it turns on a light bulb in me that something is wrong with the module.
Q.  Now we are in second place - the result is 10.26 and a few seconds later it falls.  Can you explain?
A.  When I make the measurement between the two pins between the 12 volts and the 0, I create another measurement next to the adjacent pins to see if there is a leak or to get other information through which I can see if the computer is in good working order or not, and this is the next measurement I make - I make it near the adjacent pins.  Next test: I check between low and high CAN.  I check the resistances.  I am supposed to get up to 1 ohm again and can see later in the test I get values of 30,20 but the resistance is inconsistent.  It is flickering.  The voltages are not constant.  You can see that the monitor is flickering.  From here I have already stopped the test.  To the court's question, when I take the worn and red wire that you see in the picture and touch it, I get inconsistent values, it means that the computer's brain/card is damaged.  That's why I stopped the test." (See his testimony of June 9,2025, pp.  116-118).

Previous part1...5859
60...125Next part
Skip to content