Caselaw

Causing Death by Negligent Driving (Eshed) 96-05-24 Southern District Attorney’s Office – Criminal v. Shai Yosef Haddad - part 60

October 19, 2026
Print

To the court's question, even if there were consistent values and even if the computer's card was in good working order because of your comment that the key was In Switch and the module continues to log events, we will never accept the events of the time of the accident, the expert testified:
"In addition to that, I would like to add that when an output comes out of a Kia and Hyundai computer, it comes out without a chassis number.  What is missing in the video.  For some reason it does not appear there, I asked to remove the chassis number of the Kia from the police terminal.  I will declare to you that the output is truthful and I typed the chassis number.  I refer to paragraph 13 of my opinion to the unloading report on page 3: I did not have the vehicle license before me, and I remove the information from the Ministry of Transportation's database where the chassis number is located.  For the court's question, the chassis number is important so that I link it to the car." (See his testimony of June 9,2025, p.  118, paras.  17-22).

The cross-examination of the expert witness was spread over two sessions.
In his cross-examination, the expert witness testified, because he has a study certificate and certificates of completion of a course
The equivalent of the examiners' course.

To the question of whether beyond his initial exposure in the field of CDR, he was not examined afterwards and did not receive
Certification in the fieldtestified that he did not.  According to him, he is managing an international group of researchers from all over the world.
The World.  He's constantly dealing with EDR and CDR.

The expert witness was asked whether his participation in the course meant that he was an expert.  The defendant's counsel objected to the question.  The witness replied:
"Counsel for the accuser:
To Beyham's question"Q, if the computer shreds previous records, do I need all the witness's testimony?
II"The defendant:
I said his testimony was unnecessary.
II20 The accuser:
All his testimony is superfluous.  I only agree that...
II"The defendant:
For the record: I'm ready ...  I acted according to the court's commandments, I observed...
II20 The accuser:
I want to investigate it.
...
A.  I am certified as a CDR, authorized to unload data.  (See his testimony of June 9,2025, p.  120, paras.  7-30).

Previous part1...5960
61...125Next part
Skip to content