| Tel Aviv-Jaffa District Court | |
| 26 October 2026 | |
| Criminal Case 19066-05-21 State of Israel v. Lieber
|
|
| Before the Honorable Judge Shmuel Melamed | ||
|
The Accuser |
State of Israel |
|
|
Against
|
||
| The Defendant | Yitzhak Lieber ID card. xxxxxxxxx
|
|
|
Verdict
|
Content
Introduction. 3
Introduction. 3
The Structure of the Verdict 4
The Indictment 6
General Part 6
The facts of the indictment 7
The Defense Position and the Response to the Indictment 8
The parties' arguments. 9
The accuser's arguments. 9
The Defense's Arguments. 11
The Ottoman Settlement [Old Version] 1916Summary of the Arenas of Dispute 12
12-34-56-78 Chekhov v. State of Israel, P.D. 51 (2)Discussion and Decision. 14
The Admissibility and Weight of the Defendant's Confession to the Police - A Hearing on the Minor Claims 15
Legal Framework - Admissibility of the Defendant's Confession. 16
The alleged improper investigators' actions. 19
Arrest of the defendant at the airport 19
Questioning of the Defendant in the Car 20
Violation of the right to consultation. 24
Holding a conversation with the lawyer on the loudspeaker in the presence of the interrogators 26
Seduction and deception, and linking the defendant's confession to his release from detention 30
Disparaging discourse on the part of researchers. 33
Unnecessarily aggravating suspicion. 36
Unlawful intrusion into the defendant's phone. 39
A conversation from the defendant's daughter during the interrogation and violations of the Wiretapping Law.. 42
Seizure of all of the defendant's property as leverage. 47
Accumulation of the alleged defects. 48
Weight of Ganor's Message. 49
The Defense's Arguments. 49
The accuser's arguments. 51
Contradictions in Ganor's statements and testimony. 53
Pelginan Divora. 55
Pressure by the Interrogators - The External Weight of Ganor's Confession. 55
Weaving a plot 62
Lieber's version of work. 63
Defense Witnesses Media Advisors. 65
Artifact Evidence. 68
The Weight of Ganor's Testimony. 69
David Sharan - Public Servant 70
Proving guilt 73
The defendant's version in the police as it emerges from his statements. 74
The defendant's version in court 76
The Defendant's Version of the Defense's Approach. 78
The Defendant's Version of the Accuser's Approach. 79
Analysis of the Defendant's Version. 79